VAT scheme on 'excess' MOT charges
Hi all! Thanks for taking the time to read this.
As the title suggests need some information on the treatment of MOT and VAT. I have done some research and would like some input on the conclusion reached if willing?
Client is a VAT registered business in the automobile repair industry. Client does not conduct MOT tests however subcontract this and charges the customer the cost plus a mark up.
Should the MOT charge be: (i) outside the scope of VAT; (ii) standard VAT on mark up ('excess' hereafter) or (iii) standard VAT on cost plus mark up.
Research and conclusion
I have reviewed VTAXPER48000 and VTAXPER39000.
The MOT charge would be (i) outside the scope of VAT as "provided the unapproved garage charges on the exact amount it has been charged by the test centre and shows this separately on the invoice to its customer, it may treat this element as a disbursement and also outside the scope of VAT".
The MOT charge would be (ii) standard VAT on mark up as "any amount charged by an unapproved garage to its customer over and above the amount charged by the test centre is consideration for its own service of arranging the test as agent of the customer and is taxable at the standard rate".
The MOT charge would be (iii) standard VAT on cost plus mark up as "if the unapproved garage chooses not to treat the exact amount charged by the test centre as a disbursement, or otherwise does not satisfy all the conditions set out in VTAXPER39000, it must account for VAT on the full invoiced amount".
The 8 conditions stated in VTAXPER39000 being:
- the person acted as an agent of his client when he paid the third party;
- the client and not the agent used the goods and services supplied by the third party (in practice, this is usually the key condition);
- the client was responsible for paying the third party;
- the agent was authorised by his client to pay the third party on his behalf;
- the client knew that the goods or services were to be provided to him by a third party;
- the agent’s outlay is separately itemised when he invoices the client;
- the amount recovered from the client is exactly the same amount as paid to the third party;
- the goods or services paid for by the agent are clearly additional to the agent’s own supplies.
How rigorously should these be tested - would it be a fair assumption that most automobile repair business subcontracting MOT would meed these conditions by default?
- Sage Line 50 35 1
- HMRC Agent Accounts - PAYE 118 2
- HMRC Post 188 4
- CWF1 - is it still required?? 99 1
- Duplicating Sales and COS but does not impacting bottom line? Legal? 96 1
- Any reasons for a dissolved company to comply with HMRC requesting Corporation Tax and Tax Returns 211 4
- Freelance/Employee 543 14
- Should training costs being reclaimed be deducted from gross or net salary 185 3
- Can you have two types of sales? Sales with VAT and Sale without VAT? 463 11
- VAT - How hard is it? 1,848 57
- Salary Sacrifice andy subsistence payments 318 8
- VAT FRS for a Formula 2 Racing Driver 171 3
- Employment Allowance 354 3
- RBS advising client they don't want his business 2,383 13
- Auto-enrolment staging dates, letters etc 184 4
- Overdrawn directors loan account. 967 21
- Company Structure 283 2
- The importance of Grammar 2,128 58
- Who is responsible for goods values for customs clearance? 65 1
- Accountant Specialization. 141 1
- Any knowledge of salesorder.com 400
- Chart of account segments; Balance sheet vs P&L 366
- Could and would anyone here carry out a hot file review of some non statutory audit work please? 344
- Electric Car 278
- S222 Charge 233
- IP trans to holding company 181
- Taxable Benefit for Director? 171
- Corporation tax penalties and fines on the CT600 162
- Software to Deal with Amazon and Ebay Sales 159
- Best way to convert Sage data to VT Transaction+ 153