Non Resident Executive - NIC status
Company I advise for on other matters has queried the following with me (down the pub), so I'm not acting in a professional capacity.
US Company with branches all over the world (London, Geneva, Vienna, Cape Town, Singapore, etc.) has appointed a Manx resident as their Chief Customer Officer. His contract is with the US office although he will not work there and none of his income will arise from activities in the US.
Due to the need to pay him in Sterling, he will be paid by the office in London. Although he will be based in Europe, he has no fixed office location - In effect his home in the Isle of Man is his office. He will travel all over the world (but mostly in mainland Europe and South Africa) liaising with customers and then provide feedback to the US based CEO about how to improve customer relations.
Despite the company having an office in London they have no customers in the UK. The reason for this being pure-CEO vanity.
HMRC have accepted that the executive is non-resident and employed on a foreign contract. As such he has been allocated an "NT" tax code and pays tax in the Isle of Man as a permanent Manx resident, where he was born and lives with his extended family.
The question mark comes over NIC's. Due to him being previously resident in the UK working for one of the banks, he has a UK tax code and payroll have determined that he should pay his NIC's in the UK and these should be accepted as UK contributions under the reciprocal arrangement with the Isle of Man, however the executive is adamant that he should not pay NIC's in the UK as he is non-resident and should pay them directly to the Manx treasury.
Payroll have raised the question with HMRC at Longbenton, but received no reply. I've looked for the relevant guidance, but I must admit that this situation doesn't fit into the usual boxes for non-residence.
The executive is keen to pay his NIC's to the Isle of Man government as this entitles him to maintain an enhanced pension due to local Manx contributions. Given that the company has no establishment and carries out no business on the Isle of Man it seems clear that in this scenario they believe they would save on Employer's NI.
Any guidance would be appreciated.
- Sole Trader Cessation 92 2
- Do you charge fee or % for Successful appeal against HMRC penalties? 1,362 22
- VAT flat rate scheme 302 6
- Does AE staging date cease with transfer of business? 53 1
- Does SMP and SPP go up if leave goes across 2 tax years? 99 4
- Invoice personally but declare in company? 360 9
- Sole trader startup losses and PAYE income in same year 37 1
- Overtime etc for PT employees 63 1
- First Choice Final Accounts 213 1
- Anyone had this problem?? 533 15
- Complex VAT Group 311 6
- Pre-registration VAT: can you reclaim VATon delivery costs incurred in the six months prior to registration? 59 3
- EIS relief on transferring shares to spouse 317 1
- Any Answers changes - feedback required 3,250 107
- Client's company struck off 306 7
- What rent was paid for income tax purposes? 240 2
- Reversal of Warranty Provision 114 4
- Does a building subcontractor charge VAT on his labour on a new-build? 201 5
- Penalty on dormant CT600 prior to trading 119 1
- Related party disclosures 292 4
- QROP pension input amounts 467
- HMRC BENCHMARK EXPENSES 408
- write off loan or loan to equity swap or both 406
- fraud 327
- Sole trade business in UK, but the owner works from EU 257
- Construction CIS LLP Company 240
- EPS and CIS deductions 239
- Stamp duty on house transfer between spouses 192
- SAGE winforecast 166
- LIVE: Budget aftermath webinar 160