Probiz Network

Probiz Network

Didn't find your answer?

Have anyone out there heard of Probiz Network? They claim that their Probiz system can help you to do more value added works for clients, and generate new business referrals to accountants in practice, some are in the region of £1m additional fee a year??

They have road shows and I have been so far tempted to attend one of them. However, I like to be well informed before hand. So, if you have heard about them, are they genuine? What do they do really? What is the, or type of, cost in joining them as a Probiz Accountant? And do they continuie charging referral fees? etc. etc.

Thank you for your tips.

ECL
ECL

Replies (42)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

avatar
By User deleted
20th Sep 2007 08:30

The facts
I don't think you should let the facts interfere with the message! Personally, I can't wait to see the accounts (but will have to as they haven't been filed at Companies House yet). The turnover figure will be interesting.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
26th Sep 2007 08:44

Exactly the kind of person you wouldn't want ....
Naturally questioning, sceptical of over-hyped marketing and very intollerant of "poor housekkeeping" which extends to illegally breaching Companies House regulations. You're damn right, I am the last sort of person you would want as a member.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Essex FCCA
29th Aug 2007 11:09

Thanks John
Thank you John for your quick response and I am looking forward to seeing the updated article.

Paul

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Essex FCCA
29th Aug 2007 09:36

Note to the Editors
It would be really useful if one of the Aweb team could run a feature on the various Networks Pro-Biz, AVN, RanOne & Principa as this would be independent and would featurethe advantages/disadvantages of each network and the costs involved.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Basingstoke accountant
24th Aug 2007 16:57

Probiz
I looked into this in February this year. It's very difficult to find out what they actually do without attending one of their roadshows. No doubt you have looked at the somewhat evangelistic website. I was going to go to a roadshow and started to ask questions about what they were offering - they dropped me like a stone. From talking to other people on Ecademy who are members, basically they seem to be selling sophisticated tax planning schemes and other "value added" type services. You would earn a cut of the overall commission on the scheme or project. They charge £300 plus VAT per month to be a member.

Personally I am always very wary when large sums of money are being quoted without anything to back them up.

Does anyone know different?

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
24th Aug 2007 17:33

A quick search on AW gives the following:
https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cgi?id=147977
https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cgi?id=158025
https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cgi?id=168119
https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cgi?id=168607

Interestingly their ARD is 31/08/07 and Cos House does not show their accounts as being filed. Mind you they may be in the post or awaiting processing.

A final word of advice having been a member of another "network" (initials not numbers!) be very wary of "the emperor's new clothes" syndrome producing no critical comments from members.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
26th Aug 2007 08:00

Personal experience
Our company provides a marketing and profit improvement system for accountants who work with small businesses. We have sponsored a number of PROBIZ events because they type of firms that join PROBIZ often find what we offer interesting.

So, as an ex-accountant and now strategic partner of accountants throughout the UK this is what I can tell you:

1) PROBIZ is money making opportunity for accountants. It is probably very different from anything you have probably seen.

2) I have been in a room with 300 accountants where cheques of £250,000 have been handed out to sole-traders generated by PROBIZ.

3) My old firm joined on my recommendation.

Like our solution – PROBIZ provide the bullets and support and you need to pull the trigger!

Good luck.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
26th Aug 2007 09:28

£250,000 sounds too good to be true
I know Robert and I know the amount quoted is correct but just it would be worth checking how you can earn such amounts. I know its old fashioned and in this day and age probably no longer applies but "best advice" is worth considering.

Thanks (0)
John Stokdyk, AccountingWEB head of insight
By John Stokdyk
29th Aug 2007 09:45

Note to Paul
We think it's a very good idea, Paul. That's why we asked Nigel Harris to write A brief guide to practice development gurus back in 2003.

However, Probiz did not figure on our radar then and there are a few new names that have cropped up in this and other conversations on the site. Thanks to your promptings, we'll see if we can get Nigel to bring the guide up to date in the next week or two.

John Stokdyk
Technology editor
AccountingWEB.co.uk

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
29th Aug 2007 09:49

Great idea Paul
Will Nigel be asking for members comments?

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
28th Aug 2007 13:34

Principa
On a similar note (and apologies for the diversion from the original topic) I got a flyer through last week from Principa. It all looks interesting, but does anyone

(a) know anything about Principa
(b) know how much membership costs

Thanks.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
28th Aug 2007 19:25

Not sure I agree with Mark Lee's comments
1. Mark have you been a member of a network?
2. How do you judge if it is "reputable"?
3. How does someone know if "their model" works. One network told me they could produce new clients. When I asked if they were willing to guarantee it by offering me a three month trial period with a full refund if the clients did not appear I was told they didn't give guarantees!
4. The T-shirt cliche smacks of the sort of rubbish talked by many of the networks.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
29th Aug 2007 12:27

Mixed questions
I know I shouldn't mix questions & answers but given that Nigel is about to survey the networks may I be permitted to throw in another view?

There is without doubt an American influence in the majority of the networks - examples of how to do it, how it works for others and suggested reading are often US based. Some of the owners of the networks are American.

Attitudes are different over here - just read the answers to this question https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cgi?id=171929 . In the States this question would never have been asked.


Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
28th Aug 2007 15:15

Don't be silly!
It's really simple ... there are accountants and clients. The accountant performs a competent service and is paid by the client. If you cant get enough clients you are probably not offering a good enough service and ditto if your existing clients are not paying you enough.

There are no short-cuts.

PS ... want to buy some magic beans?

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
04th Oct 2007 09:15

Why didn't you say ...
that you act as sales agents on a commission? I don't take a commission from any third party in connection to my clients ... third paragraph of my engagement letter. I find it enables me to give impartial advice.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
17th Sep 2007 09:01

I wonder ...
if they ring a bell and crack open the champagne when someone signs up at the event? That would just about tip the balance for me ....

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
04th Oct 2007 11:29

Im with Steve
...and do you tell your clients that you are collecting a commission on what you are "advising" them to invest in ?

If I had wanted to sell property/franchises I'm not sure I would have bothered with my 5 years accountancy training.
On the other hand maybe that qualification helps bring the punters through the door...............

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
03rd Oct 2007 06:40

I'm beginning to get it
Sell overseas properties to your clients and presumably earn commission on the sales. By the way the properties are "sourced" by Feisal. Oh and make sure you hold a "Real estate seminar" so the attendees can become really excited and get into the buying mood. Add a few celebrity names, book Michael Gerber (weren't RAS and AVN there first?) franchise your client's businesses "for a small retainer fee of £25,000 paid to Feisal.

Take a look at his website http://www.fngonline.com/index.php for a glimpse of the future.

But finally don't let your clients see the Financial Times article on second homes price fall http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/f8c0c580-6e63-11dc-b818-0000779fd2ac.html

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Essex FCCA
19th Sep 2007 10:37

Message for John Stokdyk
John,

Any news on the updated article yet?

Thanks alot,

Paul

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
14th Sep 2007 17:30

"Yes, Im 32 and Ive made millions....."
but not enough to pay someone to file your abbreviated accounts. Late again!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
05th Oct 2007 14:31

Barking down the wrong tree gets you in trouble!
Dear Do you research.,....

Firstly be careful not to keep branding this company different to it is - this is unethical - your guesses are wrong and you HAVE ALREADY crossed the line.

pls come out and reveal who you are and your practice so I can question who you are and what value you bring to the table as much what you have to say is factually incorrect and everything you are trying to do is be negative against things where I assume you have no expertise in.
Your views are very poor I have to be honest and I will be happy to explain facetoface ina forum below where I will donate £5k to charity if you turn up! See below...

Are we talking to someone serious or someone with minimal clients and so much free time adding no value and spending time on a forum criticising instead of openly trying to find opportunities for clients. You are not networking on here...purely acting against things you have no idea on.

Our business like all have areas where a VERY SMALL area is commission related as we have introducers and the whole point of business is to build contacts if you dont know someone else can...no one needs to take commission but theird parties often offer it. This is normal world! BUT THE MAJORITY OF OUR WORK is purely based on finding accountants new type of work and working in partnership with us where hourly rates hit the roof as we price on value - SIMPLE AS THAT.

....you made wrongful remarks on services....coz youre guessing and trying to find the bad in people and things. Your attitude is disrespectful, wrong and you pretend to be the good guy when actually you are not!

Ive proven myself to so many accountants and endorsements listed on website...ive made more money for accountants on higher hourly work than most...thats why people trust me.....i dont beg for work dont need new work so why are you bothering to get involved as you seriously are not welcome at all! We dont want youre type where clients miss out!

Most my clients are award winners and reputable accountancy firms carefully selected!

Anyway - lets see your website, your endorsements, your firms name and the value you bring to the table...if you dont I assume it says everything!

IN ADDITION....AS A MATTER OF CHARITY - I WILL DONATE £5k advance to a charity OF YOUR CHOICE, if you and i can have a face-to-face debate on areas you have discussed infront of other accountants and your clients....this is for charity and better to be facetoface than this forum....tickets will be free, prestigious 5star venue in London ON ME!

You must remember that most decent accountancy firms all look to protect themselves and their clients before engaging into any new opportunity.....thats the nature of our profession which is the correct way.

Anyway, lets meet up....the challenge is there....

Best wishes

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
05th Oct 2007 16:09

Barking up the wrong tree
I hate to be pedantic but the saying is:

Barking up the wrong tree and it can never get anyone into trouble if what is said isn't defamatory or untrue. Sorry.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
27th Sep 2007 14:45

Your secret is safe Bob ....
but please roll your trouser legs back down ... thats a different club!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
19th Sep 2007 16:34

cut out the middleman
Apparently Feisal made his fortune with Probiz on the back of business concepts purchased from Peter Thomson International plc (who he ?)
See http://www.peterthomson.com/clients_comments.htm where Feisal explains how he went from a £1m organisation to £7m in 12months apparently refering to 2006.
Quite how that squares with Feisal "handing out £20m in fees last year alone", I am not sure, but heck I'm only a simple accountant.

Still, it all sounds great to me - all this easy money - especially since I can avoid Feisal's cut by going straight to the source. More for me !
Boy, I cant wait to be a gazillionaire this time next year.........

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
27th Sep 2007 08:59

Bob's secrets for success ....
Big mistake Bob ... you could have packaged and charged for that but you had to keep it secret ...Doh!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
04th Oct 2007 22:12

Huw
Advice from an IFA is policed by the FSA. Who polices the property investments you are "selling to your clients"? Are you really justifying this "advice" by saying lots of people have made loads of money but it's "risk" for the poor sods who lose money. What do you or will you say to the clients who have lost money? Would you consider handing back your commission on the bad "investments"? How do you live with yourself selling these schemes to clients knowing there are high risks involved. A "property seminar" is not and never will be the same as advice from an IFA.

Yes chartered accountants have to run businesses but they are a profession as well. Saying that we must be businessmen doesn't allow us to forget our ethical requirements. Does your list of what you will sell to clients to make money have any limits. If so, please specify how those limits are formulated.

I'll make it easier - what due diligence did you do before sending clients to Feisal's seminars?

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
26th Sep 2007 17:37

The secret of success in Accountancy
The trouble with Probiz is that they are a secret society and cant tell you their golden secret as a non member otherwise they will have to kill you.

Well heres a very simple "secret" approach to success:

Work hard.
Do a good job of everything you take on.
Be prepared to roll up your sleeves and get your hands dirty.
Earn a good living but do not be greedy and never overcharge clients just because you can (and tell them thats your approach)
Ask your happy clients (and they will be happy if you do all the above) for referrals.
Keep doing the above, day after day.
Never forget that you dont get 'owt for nowt in this life.

There. Simple isnt it.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
26th Sep 2007 17:52

Commissions
We have introducer agreements with organisations like PROBIZ because through their marketing they sometimes find accountants for us. It's a bit like paying AccountingWeb for adverts (which we have done) and sponsoring the AccountancyAge awards this year.

Why do you ask the question? What has our lead generation strategy to do with PROBIZ?

By the way, I offered to pay PROBIZ because Feisal invited us to attend their annual conference for free - just to get to know them. Not many people do that and I prefer to look at this as a thank you.

Bob Harper

Thanks (0)
avatar
By JSJ54
26th Sep 2007 11:12

I never cease to be amazed by other "accountants" comments
First I have been in another network and I have been corresponding with Ron Baker since 1998 (a long time before most people in the UK had ever heard of him!). Although what connection Ron Baker has to Probiz fascinates me. I can only guess that throwing his name in adds some kind of respectability.

I left the network when one of the owners (a fellow chartered accountant) said he couldn't be bothered if a client analysed the purchase of a car as motor expenses and his firm didn't find it when reviewing the accounts prior to submission to HMRC - it was the client's responsibility not his. How similar that view is to the Probiz member's. Do his views of housekeeping extend to his client's deadlines? I hope not for the sake of the profession and his PI.


Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
26th Sep 2007 11:35

I admit ....
I have no idea even what the concept of Probiz or other "networks" is. So, you're right to say that I have no evidence on which to base my prejudices .......

Oh, except it sounds like every con that I have ever heard of. Maybe the problem is in how they present themsleves that lends itself so readily to my prejudice?

... and filing accounts on time is really important. PROBIZ comprises a network of accountants even if it does not provide accountancy services. Ignoring deadlines is lazy and slapdash and tells a lot of people all they need to know. Of course, the results could dispell all of this speculation.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
26th Sep 2007 11:55

The cheques
I've come to this late but why are such large amounts being paid to members? Is it some type of commission on products/services sold to clients?

I don't expect chapter & verse but an area would be interesting - tax planning/financial services/HR services/etc

Thank you.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
26th Sep 2007 11:57

Robert Harper
Do you earn or pay commission to the Probiz Network?

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
26th Sep 2007 11:01

Attitude determines your altitude
Stephen - why do you have what appears to be such a negative attitude towards PROBIZ?

It seems to me that you have slamed the door shut in your own face, just because some accounts have been filed late and without even knowing why.

I appreciate Companies House deadlines are important but how important is that compared to to creating wealth for the accountants and clients in the PROBIZ network?

I think if PROBIZ where helping firms with accounts and their accounts where late you'd have a point. But, that's not what they do.

By the way, I am interested in this because it refects what we are doing in MORE - changing what accountants do.

I like to ask accountants if they are sure all their clients are doing dividend vouchers/minutes, bank reconciliations and making full use of their CGT and IHT allowances each year as advised. Many admit that they are not 100% in order.

Bob Harper

Thanks (1)
avatar
By bwinder
27th Sep 2007 09:54

Bobs secrets for success
Steve
Damn. Missed out again.
If I pay you a fat ongoing fee will you continue to give me good advice like that ?
Hey, better still, hows about I come up with the ideas and charge you for them, then you charge me for advice on what to do with them. We could both make a lot of money. No hang on, isnt there some difference between sales and profit ? I'm sure there was something about that in my ACCA exams, but it was years ago. Probably changed by now, so not to worry.

We will of course have to keep this whole thing very secret between ourselves.

-Bob

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
20th Sep 2007 10:54

If a client came to you ...
and said they were thinking of committing a lot of money to a business which was late filing its statutory accounts, what would you advise? If what was offered seemed a little to good to be true, what would you advise? If they were very secretive and relcutant to answer questions until you had signed up, what would you advise?


Thought so.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
25th Sep 2007 19:28

It works
I'm a member, and it works. Yes, the admin is crap, and is probably the reason the accounts are late (resourcing for fast growth is always an issue), but I would much rather them concentrate on producing the goods for members than keeping their housekeeping spick and span.

With due respect, Mr Holloway is exactly the kind of member we wouldn't want. Too much to say without even attending a roadshow, and the practice development advice he dispensed half way through the thread tells you all you need to know about a narrow outlook - Has he never heard of Ron Baker?

It helps if you have a background from a previous network, because you will be attuned to possibilities, but it's not essential. Just an open mind. As someone sagely said earlier, they make the buillets but you have to fire them.

No doubt I will be dismissed as a stooge, but more fool you if you can't be bothered to attend a briefing event.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
06th Oct 2007 12:05

Why the threat?
In terms of the implied threat to him that he had stepped over a line ... my god man you do yourself no favours! it just makes you look like you have something you want to keep hidden.

If you are happy to debate your business in public and pay a charity for the privilage why does someone have to come to a seminar to learn the 'secrets of success'? Just show a seminar in full on YouTube and keep the £5k. You must appreciate that seminars have been used unethically in many hard-sell scenarios (partiularly overseas property sales) and perhaps, not surprisingly, lots of people view such events with suspicion as a result.

My comments on commissions reflected my personal view only. I am not an IFA and therefore I cannot sell or recommend financial products. By default, I am therefore not qualified to recommend an IFA to my clients. How can I accept money for doing something that I have no more expertise in than my client? Ditto property development ... its just not what I do.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
07th Oct 2007 09:00

Threats & challenges ... ethos behind the organisation ?
This thread has taken an interesting turn

There are obviously strong opinions on both sides, however, until the recent postings it has all been debate rather than insults, challenges and threats; starting with a posting that was virtually illiterate and does the author no credit (presumably not the author of the marketing literature)

From ones own point of view it would be preferable for accountants to specialise in what they are best at and have been trained to do, however, one can see that money and diversification are a strong incentive in other directions - in the end it boils down to choice

Nevertheless where does this diversification ultimately lead us? We have already seen the Banks diversifying into all sorts of 'added value' markets and customers are simply not comfortable with being sold insurance (critical illness etc) when they ask for a loan

The 'added value' phrase seems to be a cornerstone when justifying such diversification but as with the Banks it is questionable who is the beneficiary of this value; buyer or seller?

Once you trade your market specialisation for diversification do you become vulnerable by loosing the respect of the public; you are then perceived as just another high street 'bucket shop'?

The danger with this approach is that it then opens the door for others to join the party to the detriment of the profession - how long will it be before Tesco etc. decide to have a go at 'in store' tax returns etc? What’s more they would probably give 'card points' to spend on your weekly shop!

Once that happens you can forget any semblance of a sensible fee structure because everyone in the profession becomes a looser; except of course the marketeers who move on!

To re-arrange a well known saying

'.. its not the principle, its the money ..'

Thanks (0)
avatar
By AnonymousUser
07th Oct 2007 10:08

Excellent post JC
Summed up my thoughts... just more eloquently!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By markallen01
09th Oct 2007 12:47

Does PROBIZ work?
Yes PROBIZ Accountants earn good monies

Yes it helps PROBIZ Accountants build better practice.

Most importantly it helps get and retain very good clients.

No other organisation has generated similar results although some are trying with limited success to copy the model.

Whatever comments have been posted to date I am sure PROBIZ accountants will be happy to continue serving their clients to the best of their ability.

I am interested in serving clients not debating why something might not work without even trying it!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By JSJ54
09th Oct 2007 18:16

Without wanting to stir things up any more
it seems that some accountants prefer to diversify and others want to continue to concentrate on using their accountancy knowledge. I don't wish to judge which (if either) is the "best".

However, I feel I should add a comment about one of the other networks Principa http://principa.net/ . Owned by Ric Payne who with Paul Dunn, founded RAS (famous for their Bootcamps), Ric is a chartered accountant and it seems Principa base their ideas on the accountant's unique skills ie understanding the figures.

For those who want to continue being "accountants" it is probably worth a look. They have a UK office and can be contacted via their website.

I know Ric but have no business links with him.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By User deleted
01st Mar 2010 10:30

Danger!

Good advice is about understanding your clients and their objectives, about advising them rather than providing advice.  Probiz is all about devising product which can be mass-marketed and sold to everyone and sundry, irrespective of who they are and what they are trying to achieve. 

I am a senior tax person in a decent sized firm and have dealt with a number of complaints where very risky tax planning concepts have been passed off as "sure-fire" by Probiz through the accountant members.  Ultimately, Probiz only care about selling the products, it is the accountant that will lose the client in the long run (in favour of a short-term commission).  Probiz don't care about the end client and commissions are turning accountants' heads that way too!

In short-term Probiz is creating a culture found a decade ago in the under-regulated IFA world.  This is being used to exploit small firms, who do not otherwise have the capability to deliver the "advice" they think Probiz are.  Anyone that subscribes to this kind of network is endangering their own clients, their own business reputation and also the profession as a whole!  You have been warned.....

 

    

Thanks (0)