Client accusation about all UK accountants working for HMRC
I had a really strange letter from a (now former) client this week that is a UK born and resident IT Contractor of Indian descent working for a finance house in Canary Wharf.
As is our wont, a few months ago he had come to me with one of those ludicrous 'man down the pub' schemes, whereby he was going to continue to operate his UK company as previously, but instead of paying the UK's 'extortionate' corporation taxes and such, he would sub-contract an offshore company based in a tax haven to undertake the actual work (actually performed by him at some bank in Canary Wharf) and then the offshore company would invoice the UK company extracting the majority of profits tax free and just paying him enough to live on.
He justified this as being 'all right' as he was going to retire at 50 and live in India and he needed it to setup his retirement fund.
After looking at him aghast for about 30-seconds I pointed out to him why this was probably a bad idea in that it was a fairly obvious attempt at tax evasion which would (once discovered by HMRC) be subject to full repayment of unpaid tax, a penalty of up to 200% of the tax due, interest and the possibility of a jail sentence for willful tax evasion. I then explained about things like SOCA and Money Laundering, etc.
From that point onwards the meeting petered out and it wasn’t raised again.
Then out of the blue last week, I received a letter from him effectively saying that he was unhappy that he was paying me a lot of money, but that if he did anything wrong I was going to ‘report him to the taxman” and accusing me of working for HMRC rather than the guy who was paying the bill.
Since he could no longer ‘trust any UK accountant’ he was arranging to have his brother-in-law who is an accountant in Pune, India deal with his affairs and that he would make arrangements in the coming weeks.
He’s paid his latest bill, so there is no concern over fees, but I’m just wondering what (if anything) I should do from here. He’s within his rights to get anyone to do his accounts if he feels they are appropriate and qualified, but I suspect the real reason is that he would like to go ahead with his crackpot scheme and is using the Indian accountant as a way to bypass SOCA and Money Laundering Regulations.
I don’t really want to report this unless I have to as if HMRC come knocking it will be pretty obvious that I was the one that made the report; certainly I have no evidence of anything untoward, just a sneaking suspicion.
Equally, wouldn’t an Indian accountant be bound by equivalent legislation over there, even if he was preparing accounts for a UK based company?
Thoughts and comments please (after you’ve stopped laughing)...
- P11D Rejection 367 9
- How to avoid a bankruptcy 518 14
- Selling a practice 342 5
- KPMG email campaign and impact on market 1,266 20
- Incapable of reading 123 1
- How to pay national insurance 141 2
- Overlap relief 461 12
- Live Chat on Accountancy Website 111 1
- Related party - Transaction with sole director’s father 81 1
- Dormant payroll 838 9
- Form 17 - legal ownership requirements 177 5
- Can I get around an ostrich director? 135 1
- "Can your client afford the following" 1,334 21
- Why won't CH validate accounts? 624 13
- PPR exemption on separation 146 1
- P11DX: change of requirement by HMRC 1,549 10
- Intercompany loans 111 1
- How do I create a tax journal from my corporation tax return? 180 3
- Limited Company 340 11
- Sage renewals and terminations 133 1
- Theatre Tax Relief 442
- Has anyone been affected by the RBS payment breakdown? 346
- Windows 10 on-going support ... 336
- Straight line write off of Purchase Goodwill ??? 311
- Perkbox 274
- Compensation - Taxable or not then CGT or IT 242
- FRS 102 compliant illustrative accounts for an insurance company 242
- Self Assessment - What to enter on the return 237
- Document Management Systems 215
- WIP Software 199