Employed or self-employed
A new client (partnership) organises events, mainly themed childrens parties. The event will cost the customer, for example, £200. A booking fee is paid when the booking is made (£100) and this is paid directly to the partnership. The partnership then send an actor to the event to run the actual party and the customer pays the remaining fee (£100) direct to the actor which he/she retains as their fee.
The partnership arranges the event, calls the actor to give them the details, provides a script to follow at the event. The partnership uses three actors to host the events (though will increase this if demand grows) and events are alternated between them according to availability. When an actor is first used they are presented with a pack including all costumes etc required for the events.
Under normal badges of trade, indicators of employment are the fact that the actors are provided with equipment, given specific instructions as to how to perform their tasks and are expecting ongoing work (although this is totally dependent on bookings). Indicators of self-employment are, the fact that they can turn down events if they wish (in which case the partnership would need to contact one of the other actors, the actors themselves do not provide substitutes), they are paid a fixed fee regardless of how long the event is for, they do not get paid if there are no events.
As an additional point I believe that there are different rules for entertainers when determining employment status, compared to other categories of workers.
I would be extremely grateful any any readers able to offer :
(a) an indication of the likely employment status of the actors
(b) an indication of whether the different rules for entertainers would apply in this case.
(c) How those rules can be applied in this case to determine self-employment
(d) Any ideas, if employment is the likely status, of any changes that could be made to the arrangement to weight the status in favour of self-employment.
As as additional point the subject of VAT and turnover threshold is also a matter of concern. In the example above I would be interested to establish whether readers would consider the turnover for the event to be £100 only, or £200 (with a cost of £100). This makes a huge difference to the VAT position as the former is likely to see the business well below the VAT registration threshold, the latter will see it exceeded.
I would be most grateful for readers opinions on all or any of the above. Thank you.
- Really?! 617 9
- What would you do here, potential insolvency. 239 4
- Bookkeeping question for Finance Lease payments 125 3
- Dominant influence and intercompany loans 224 5
- Company Car for Owner Director number crunching - is there a ready reckoner? 439 6
- How did you recalculate your payroll fees 874 12
- Is the CT61 return dead? 250 4
- Car Purchase 99 1
- Directors liability insurance and scope 150 7
- IR35 92 1
- Car benefit or not? 1,879 18
- Auto Enrolment - Help each other by sharing known problems 262 3
- Questions from Liquidator 2,256 24
- Drawing Down Directors Current account 1,567 9
- backpack 217 2
- Separate companies same Director buy from each other 575 11
- VAT - Medical Staff 131 1
- VAT 701/49 query 179 1
- FCA regulated company in a small group 382 1
- Are you going to Xerocon? 1,164 27
- Self employed and HMRC Worldwide Subsistence Rates 702
- 2015 tax year end 433
- Interest paid - do new rules affect Tax Credits? 411
- Self employed consultant working in Ireland 349
- Costly Accounting Software contract 298
- Market Invoice (P2P invoice discounting) tax treatment 254
- Directors' advances and credits 246
- DTA tie-breaker issue 238
- Tax on internet ad sharing income 218
- Credit against UK NI for NI paid to EEC Countries 199