employee? subject to minimum wage?
I'm working with an educational charity for Autistic Spectrum Disorder young people aged 18 - 25. They receive all the funding from a governement agency and do not charge the young people to be here.
As part of the education curriculum work experience is offered in the various social enterprise functions that the college runs.
Because of the nature of the young people they are unable to be left alone doing any work in the enterprises but are always supervised with a proficient staff member - However they do do actual work, low level stuff like stacking boxes, moving things around, cleaning tables etc.
If a student works in one of these enterprises they are 'paid' £3 per hour - less than the minimum wage, they are not treated as employees and no returns to HMRC are done for them. To put this in context the maximum any one student might earn from this would be around £250 per year. It is highly unlikely that they would have a 'proper' job elsewhere given their circumstances - although not impossible by any means - so they would probably never break any tax thresholds.
The issue I am grappling with is:
Is this real employment or is it some kind of sheltered work enabling work skills to be learned ready for the real world - i.e it's all part of their education.
if the latter - should we be paying them at all? is it a problem that we do?
In terms of employment law it seems to me that there is no mutuality of obligation in that if work is offered to the young person and they don't turn up, or they wandered off in the middle of the day, then there would be no reprocussions - the other proficient worker in the shop would manage without them - they would not be sacked, or disciplined it would just be a learning point for them to consider that they have had a negative impact on something as a result of their actions.
Therefore they are not employees in terms of full employment rights but that would just makes them casual labourers still subject to minimum wage.
The whole purpose for offering the 'work' is for the students benefit - to gain experience of interfacing with the public and to see work as a positive thing. It isn't to actually get any work out of them as such - even though work can and does get done, but if it didn't it would be picked up by someone else on site.
So should it be minumum wage or nothing at all......
at present we are somewhere in the middle - a middle that I don't think exists.
- The stupidity continues 643 25
- Limited company director - other earnings in the tax year 233 4
- transactions after account have been closed 190 4
- Can I claim Vat on solicitors invoices? 175 5
- CIMA at the age of 35?? 536 10
- Offsetting CT losses against another company 226 6
- Calculating capital gains tax for non-residents UK residential property 129 1
- CIS. Why is it so complicated? 2,340 25
- New Employers Helpline 210 4
- Software recommendations 277 1
- Share transfer question 381 17
- Land Rover Discovery 3.0 SDV6 255 Comm Auto 2 seat 332 7
- qualifying for 1/9th tax credit on foreign dividend 189 2
- HMRC & daft penalty 2,459 19
- Overlap relief 759 19
- What is IRIS World like? 369 8
- Pension contributions 384 10
- Do you have to declare business expenditure on a personal credit card on your P11D? 512 11
- Do you use sign up lists on your website 213 1
- Setting up PAYE scheme without UTR 289 8
- Has anyone been affected by the RBS payment breakdown? 440
- Straight line write off of Purchase Goodwill ??? 436
- WIP Software 301
- FRS 102 compliant illustrative accounts for an insurance company 291
- No payroll scheme in place 235
- CGT, PPR and transfer of equity to spouse. 233
- Do subcontractors on work for residential (student accomodation) construction 210
- Is there anything wrong with this? 205
- Small Part Disposal of Property 190
- Uncommercial property business 182