HMRC career path?

HMRC career path?

Didn't find your answer?

Hi Everyone,

I am interested in applying to the HMRC Graduate Program once it opens up and apart from moving up through the HMRC ranks what other career options would be open to me later on?

Is there a demand from the private sector for Ex-HMRC staff?

Is there anyone on here that is ex-HMRC and went on to start their own practise?

Any guidance would be most appreciated.

Replies (24)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

By mrme89
11th Aug 2014 17:09

I don't think HMRC would equip you with the skills and tax knowledge required to open your practice.

Thanks (1)
avatar
By User deleted
11th Aug 2014 17:15

But...

But you'd develop the thick skin required to be a traffic warden. And there will always be a demand for them!

Thanks (1)
chips_at_mattersey
By Les Howard
11th Aug 2014 17:31

Career Path

Most tax practitioners have learned their trade in large Accountancy practices.  (I am an exception, having worked in HMCE (as it was then) before moving into the private sector.)

I would comment that staff morale is currently low in HMRC, and it might not be the the best option at the moment.

Is there a sizeable local Accountant with vacancies? That would give you a range of career options, and develop technical and other skills.

Thanks (0)
By johngroganjga
11th Aug 2014 17:37

I have seen many HMRC employees, at different levels, jump ship and join practising firms.  They have always been in demand for their technical knowledge and I can't see why that would change.

I agree however that going straight from HMRC to running one's own practice is unlikely to work.

Thanks (1)
avatar
By User deleted
12th Aug 2014 20:05

Why would anyone ...

... want to make a living depriving others of theirs?

My view of ex-HMRC in practice is akin to how lags see coppers in clink!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By jazzhands
12th Aug 2014 18:19

Well my plan would be :
4/6 years - HMRC
4 years - Private Firm

Then maybe my own practise or reevaluate my options.

Is that within the realms of possibility?

Thanks (0)
By johngroganjga
12th Aug 2014 19:58

Yes it's possible but 4 years is not a long time to develop the contacts with clients and work referrers to form the basis of a viable practice. Why not take it a stage at a time? You might love it at HMRC and rise to the top there. Or you might jump ship into private practice and rise to become senior partner of a large firm.

Thanks (1)
By Moonbeam
12th Aug 2014 20:25

A word of warning

I was attracted by the bright lights of the Civil Service when I was 19 back in 1974. They were advertising Executive Officer jobs using pictures of dynamic looking people standing next to cars as if they were going somewhere.

So I sat through the exacting interviews on my politics etc. Then they gave me a mind blowingly boring job. When I asked for a change a year later I got an even more tedious one. My bosses' attitude to making decisions was - what did we do last year?

There wasn't an ounce of original thought to be had. I was surrounded by very bright people of my own age who were bored to tears, but who had no ambition and seemed destined to spend their days there. So I got a job in commerce as a trainee accountant. My leaving card from the Civil Service was signed by the "escape society". Lovely people though they were, it was stifling not being encouraged to use any initiative.

My friends from the Civil Service (all now retired on large pensions) tell me that things tightened up since I left and that people are expected to use their initiative now.

All I can say looking at HMRC from the outside is that anyone with initiative has left to join an accountancy practice, leaving the also rans doing an impossible job with unreasonable demands placed on them by the nitwits who run the show.

Why not start off in private practice and keep any eye out in case HMRC starts recruiting people who are allowed to think for themselves. (Don't hold your breath on this one).

Thanks (1)
avatar
By jazzhands
13th Aug 2014 11:19

Thanks for your input guys it is genuinely appreciated.

I have decided that the HMRC option would be secondary to a private firm.

Thanks (0)
paddle steamer
By DJKL
13th Aug 2014 12:03

I would be slightly more positive

 

Having looked at the website re the graduate programme they appear to be indicating that the trainee would be put through professional exams, albeit they do not seem to state which.

In addition the minimum starting salary at circa £27k possibly rising to near £40k during the four year training period and if successful then a salary of nearly £47k thereafter does not look that bad. (graduate at say 22, may be on £47k by age 26)

The graduate entry programme is at a level above Executive Officer (used to be Tax Officer Higher Grade in HMRC in the 1980s when I applied but did not join) so not sure how "boring" the programme would be.

I would do a bit more digging about the actual qualifications that would be on offer before rejecting the idea.

Thanks (0)
Replying to Montrose:
avatar
By Manwithnoname
15th Aug 2014 12:46

Surely you jest

DJKL wrote:

In addition the minimum starting salary at circa £27k possibly rising to near £40k during the four year training period and if successful then a salary of nearly £47k thereafter does not look that bad. (graduate at say 22, may be on £47k by age 26)

"Does not look that bad".  I hope that's sarcasm... not many practices will take school leavers/graduates and pay them anything like that.  I'd watch paint dry for £47k... (in fact at 22 I'd have watched paint dry for £27k).

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Jaxter
15th Aug 2014 12:08

Cutting the mustard ?

You should apply for the Fast Stream.  If you get accepted for that at HMT or HMRC then you'll be offered really stretching opportunities (like working on new tax laws/policies) that wont be available outside.  And being a Faster Streamer will open doors outside that may have been closed before.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Exector
15th Aug 2014 12:16

@ Jaxter

The Graduate Program is what constitutes the Fast Stream nowadays

Thanks (0)
By ireallyshouldknowthisbut
15th Aug 2014 12:20

.

Sheesh they let "freshouts" lose on working on new tax laws and policies?

That perhaps explains a huge amount.

 

Thanks (2)
avatar
By [email protected]
15th Aug 2014 12:38

Practise -v- Practice

A great many HMRC staff eventually join the other side where they are always in demand, but relatively few start their own practices, (Please get the spelling right if you're thinking of going into business - you've repeatedly used the verb 'practise' when your context required the noun 'practice')  

Though they undergo rigorous training and face stiff examinations, HMRC staff don't generally end up with recognised chartered qualifications and have to undertake farther training and exams if they want to progress in the outside world. 

Thanks (1)
Morph
By kevinringer
15th Aug 2014 13:51

Whoops

Posted to wrong thread in error

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Exector
15th Aug 2014 13:38

Further not farther

....... glass houses etc

Thanks (5)
Replying to mrme89:
avatar
By [email protected]
15th Aug 2014 17:34

Farther -v- Further

FARTHER - (Adverb) 1) to or at a greater distance in space or time; 2) in addition;

               - (Adjective) 3) more distant or remote in space or time;  4) additional.

 

Admittedly, 'farther' is more commonly used in its literal sense of 'more far', but as the above extract from Collins Dictionary confirms, it's equally legitimate in the figurative sense to mean 'additional'.  So what's the problem?

Thanks (1)
paddle steamer
By DJKL
15th Aug 2014 13:50

I think it depends on your subject area and University

I think salary expectations post University are influenced by both subject area and the calibre of the institution you attended.

A fair number of graduates from "top 20" universities (If you trust the Times etc lists) start at around the £25k mark even outwith London. My son (age 22) has just left an old Scottish University and started in July as a software developer with a large employer at £25k plus benefits. His former flatmate, who graduated last year, also Computer Science,  started on £25k last year with a different company and I have heard is now earning circa £45k age 23; these salaries are in Scotland not London.

I maybe phrased things poorly, the £47k is AFTER completing the 4 years training not as a graduate entrant and the scheme appears to not be open to school leavers just to graduates; whilst is states minimum 2:2, I suspect few without a strong 2:1 will get selected.

 

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Tosie
15th Aug 2014 14:23

Go for it

I know somebody who is currently on the graduate program. He is enjoying it and all his study leave is paid. In house training is  excellent  and exam fees  are all paid for.

He is doing the CTA exams as well as the internal exams.

You will be a very attractive proposition for many accountancy practices and then who knows.

 

Thanks (0)
Replying to Tax Dragon:
avatar
By jazzhands
16th Aug 2014 23:33

Thanks for that bit of input because I would have intended to start the CTA after the 4 year program. Would save me a lot of time!

Thanks (0)
avatar
By cparker87
15th Aug 2014 20:35

I got rejected
I planned to join HMRC some time ago. Unfortunately despite ACA/CTA I don't hold a degree and so they would not even consider my application.

I often think it would be lovely to be on the other side. It would be so easy. Never wrong. Unaccountable. Lovely.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By howlin wolf
16th Aug 2014 18:00

Be wary about the advice here. Most of them have never passed an exam or have any qualifications. They claim it would be "so easy" to work in HMRC. At HMRC you will have proper training and a good grounding to further your career with a proper professional accounting firm. The experience you gain with HMRC will be invaluable.

Thanks (1)
avatar
By FMtaxation
18th Aug 2014 17:38

Starting with HMRC

Admittedly a while ago since I was at HMCE, but it was a good start into tax , and I started on a fast track programme too, with twelve others of similar age (mid twenties) . I was not a graduate but I had had 6 six years working experience as a manager in a large company, so I was treated as being at the same level.

We were all, with the exception of one, headhunted after finishing exams to go out to accountancy firms, and our experience working for the `other side' was seen as invaluable. 29 years later when I tell clients that I am ex Inland Revenue it is still seen as an asset. I am still in practice, but still working for other firms as well as running my own; I find the environment working for other people is less isolating, and ideas come better when you can discuss the cases. I did not start my own practice until I had been in tax for twelve years, and even then had a lot to learn about running your own business. Don`t rush in, and good luck!

 

 

 

 

 

Thanks (1)