IR35 Accounted for incorrectly ??

I have recently taken over a couple of clients who work solely for one client, they are HGV drivers who currently work for a sole agency.

They work set hours and are told where to go and what to do, so they are clearly caught within IR35. But heres my problem their previous accountant had not told them about IR35 and was putting through the minimum salary and claiming dividends rather than putting them through on full salary. Now my client is saying that they should be treated as outside of the scope of IR35. How do i go about this now?

My other question is this... am i right in thinking that anyone that is working solely for one client, that is told where to go, what to do, cannot produce a substitute if needed is caught within IR35? It doesn't matter about what industry they are in, or if they have a contract or not?

Sorry if i am sounding thick but IR35 is really confusing me at the moment as i keep hearing different stories. 

Comments
There are 2 comments. Login or register to view them.

The short answer is that ...

Steve Holloway |
Steve Holloway's picture

It comes down to the vagaries of IR35

frustratedwithhmrc |
frustratedwithhmrc's picture