I have a client for whom we reduced POA to nil as we expected dividends to be lower for 2013/14 vs 2012/13 and drop below the higher rate threshold.
Turns out they have drawn a heap of cash so will be firmly higher rate for 2013/14.
The quantum of this is 2012/13 was £60k each
Reduced POA to nil (ie expecting £40K)
But back to the £60k more or less for 2013/14.
I assume HMRC would not bat an eyelid for a "first offence?". They have been a client for a while and not done this before.
The penalty in theory is up to 100% of the missing POA but this does seem to be only for "persistent offenders"
http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/emmanual/em4660.htm
Do we agree the client should be fine and not fined?
Replies (5)
Please login or register to join the discussion.
What was the reason for them changing their mind about how much they were going to draw in dividends between the date their returns were submitted and 5 April 2014?
What I'm getting at was whether the belief at the time the returns were submitted was honestly held and soundly based. Only if it wasn't are penalties even a theoretical possibility.
I agree with John
And it is only exceptionally that penalties are charged (I have never see that in my career), so I reckon your client will be OK.
The final para of the manual you quote seems most relevant
... and the first sentence "The intention of the penalty is to prevent gross or persistent abuse."
If, as John says, the view was a reasonable at the time of the original application and that is then corrected when the return is prepared and actual fact are known, then the interest charge should be it. I have to say I have yet to see a penalty, but always keep a trail of correspondence and computation to back up a reduced payment claim.
Dividends might be a slightly more difficult one to argue, against something that comes from an accounting adjustment - large AIA claim or allowable provision for example affecting a year, but as a one off one would hope that it would not come to a penalty, after all "If the taxpayer makes an accurate self assessment, no actual tax loss will result from the claim to reduce payments on account. Payment of tax properly due will simply have been deferred, and interest will be payable on the deferred tax. "