Removing non-existent debtors
We've taken on a client who switched accountants to us as they weren't getting a decent level of service; it's been over 3 months but we've finally just about got the professional clearance documents.
The accounts are showing debtors of ~£3000. We've been through the last two years, and there are no debtors, so we're convinced that it's not right. We've reconstructed the sales ledger and have proved the turnover figures are correct for the last accounts completed. It's not obvious what else could be wrong to get the debtors wrong. It's a very simple one-man-service-business limited company and there were definitely no debtors. No accrued income. The previous accountant says the debtors are sales invoices, but all invoices were clearly paid into the bank in the year, so there are no trade debtors.
They're on flat rate VAT so we have taken that into account as well, and that doesn't explain it either. The bank is reconciled.
We are stumped. The previous accounts balance, but they are wrong. All the other figures on the balance sheet and P&L look reasonable, nothing else leaps out as to where the other side of the error could be. I don't expect the previous accountant to either assist further or re-do them.
The correct answer is of course to get us to re-do the last accounts but of course the client may not wish to pay us to re-do them when they've already paid someone else to do them, and been fined £375 for late filing of the accounts through no fault of their own (and are unlikely to get their money back or make a complaint; for reasons I don't want to go into please take my word on this).
If the previous set of accounts are not re-done, from a taxation persepctive it will be the client out of pocket not HMRC, so there is no tax evasion/ MLR issue here.
My question is this: If the client won't get the previous accounts re-done, where would you put the debit to get rid of the debtors? The only solution I can think of is bad debts, and add back on the tax comp, but this will exacerbate an overdrawn directors loan account (due to reduction in reserves and thus dividends). Or carry the figure forward? Definitely not correct.
- Company Limited Liability vs Public Liability Insruance 105 2
- Dividend dates 652 12
- Do I need a smartphone? 1,528 47
- Company no longer showing on Companies House web site 280 7
- Companies House change of shareholding 564 16
- corporation tax 423 3
- Self Assessment Tax Return Required ???? 155 5
- Deleted question? 462 9
- Yorkshire Day 462 31
- Agent help line - long queues? 176 3
- Company Director In Prison 612 13
- pretty multi rainbow -coloured client spreadsheets 1,271 23
- Update workbook linkage without opening source 185 6
- calculation DTR restriction 183 5
- MAAT vs ACCA 604 11
- Flat rate VAT 309 6
- Redundancy pay for directors? 1,321 15
- Can I take action against my accountant for incompetence? 3,857 72
- CRM systems? 120 2
- Accountancy Career 570 13
- Have you staged yet for auto enrolment? 566
- Cancelled 451
- Cancelled 377
- SAGE Payroll Data for Import to MS Dynamics AX 368
- Probiz 347
- Free-standing washing machine - unfurnished lettings 347
- Phishing emails purporting to be from CIPFA? 251
- Is this UK incapacity benefit taxable in UK or Jersey? 226
- Another HMRC computer glitch? 220
- More spam 176