Unreasonable bank manager
Just doubting myself and could do with knowing what other practitioners would do..
Situation is that I have a client selling their business. I prepared "selling accounts" i.e. an adjusted profit & loss account with depreciation, interest and directors remuneration removed which I understand is the protocol in these instances and have never had a problem in the past doing likewise for many clients.
This time, however, the buyer's bank manager is being a pain in the posterior and is wanting far more information, i.e. balance sheet, depreciation, details of the business debts, how it's financed etc. Obviously I can tell the client to send the full company accounts which would show all this, but should he do so? My feeling is that the bank manager is taking the mickey and asking for completely irrelevant information. I feel that providing this level of detail may jeopardise my client's position as it would show how much the business was bought for intitially, how much debt the company has, etc., thus giving far too detailed a picture of how much profit they may make on the sale and how desperate they may be to sell. My view is that if you were selling a house, you wouldn't tell the buyer how much you paid for it and how much your mortgage was would you?
I have a sinking feeling that the bank manager simply doesn't know his stuff. Or possibly worse, that he doesn't understand that the buyer is buying the goodwill, equipment etc from my client company, and NOT buying the shares from the existing shareholders. In this latter case, I can of course see that the bank manager would need to know all about the company, but even then, surely he'd want proper due diligence and not just a look at the full accounts? And anyway, why is the bank manager worrying about balance sheet items - surely he should be asking the buyer to prepare a business plan to support his borrowing applications which the buyer's accountant would prepare?
My instinct is that the bank manager is an idiot and that the client should resist sending such detailed information. To my mind, the adjusted profit & loss account, supported by perhaps copies of recent VAT returns, details of stocks and debtor payment patterns would be more than enough for the buyer/buyer's accountant to put together a business plan to support borrowings. Or perhaps it's me being a fool? Anyone?
- Continuity of Practice 134 2
- IRIS Professional Yearend 96 2
- Letting Agents - requirement for audit of clients accounts 295 10
- Scams are not always obvious 2,169 34
- Financial statements accounting policies 234 5
- Does Members voluntary liquidation require change of year end 131 3
- Market Value/Connected Persons 286 10
- Online Downtime 328 4
- P60 from HMRC Basic Paye Tools 314 3
- Can I record depreciation, prepayments and accrued expenses in cash accounting? 205 3
- FPS or EPS 90 1
- What do you all do in your spare time? 774 31
- Personal allowance 666 15
- How do we get US withholding tax back? 167 2
- I have let a client go as it wasnt worth the hassle, 1,942 16
- Google contacts sharing within our domain 441 6
- New Fangled Penalties 1,115 1
- TaxCalc - A Return to Form 317 3
- New client has not reported director's pay by RTI 395 10
- VAT on employee loan 302 5
- Moving away from CCH software 943
- QROP pension input amounts 434
- write off loan or loan to equity swap or both 376
- HMRC BENCHMARK EXPENSES 351
- Unused Losses and Post Cessation Receipts 317
- fraud 276
- EIS relief on transferring shares to spouse 247
- Sole trade business in UK, but the owner works from EU 216
- Construction CIS LLP Company 205
- EPS and CIS deductions 191