Wetherspoon loses capital allowances appeal

JD Wetherspoon (JDW) has lost its latest appeal to claim capital allowances for pub refurbishments in a slightly surreal tax tribunal which included detailed discussions about toilet cubicle partitions.

The pub group had already lost two appeals against decisions by HMRC in 1999 and 2003 to prevent it from claiming capital allowances for expenditure on the fitting out and refurbishing of some of its pubs.

The latest appeal - heard in the Upper Tribunal - JD Wetherspoon (JDW) v The Commissioners for Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC, FTC/05 & 83/2010, UKUT 42 - focused on whether items in the refurbishment of the Prince of Wales pub (parts of kitchens and toilets) could be included in a claim for allowances on plant or machinery.

Continued...

» Register now

The full article is available to registered AccountingWEB members only. To read the rest of this article you’ll need to login or register.

Registration is FREE and allows you to view all content, ask questions, comment and much more.

Comments

Preliminaries & Partitions

Andy3T | | Permalink

The actual judgement is, inevitably more nuanced. The comments on the apportionment of preliminaries (a clear win for Wetherspoons) in para 98 is priceless. Para 87 on toilet partitions is something of a surprise given that HMRC had accepted the treatment by Wetherspoons and I expect them to challenge claims going forward given the comments.

Donald2000's picture

JD Wetherspoon

Donald2000 | | Permalink

I dont see any great surprise in this, to be quite frank. Of course fixtures and fittings dont qualify for CA's under Plant and Machinery. Obviously JDW need to change their accountants, if this is the standard of fantasy that these people want to come out with.

They are probably along the same lines as the MPs expenses scandal - of course I can claim for a duckhouse, old boy. Quite delusional really.

 

plummy1's picture

I think you could be wrong?

plummy1 | | Permalink

Fixtures and fittings can & do fall under the heading of Plant and Machinery. Door handles and door closers are for instance classed as machinery as are door locks. The definition for plant is any item which is necessary to the business other than the premises and supports the trade (I could be paraphrasing). Wetherspoons do try and push the boundaries in terms of capital allowances claims and they are very good at extracting every ounce of value out of it. Probably another reason why they can sell beer so cheaply.

I agree about the duck house although if he ran a profitable nature reserve he might of been able to claim CAs unless it counted as the premises of course.

 

Nichola Ross Martin's picture

But, Wetherspoons did not lose on all the points

Nichola Ross Martin | | Permalink

There was actually a cross appeal and the Tribunal DID find in favour re. preliminaries and some of the instalation costs.

Virtual Tax Support for accountants: www.rossmartin.co.uk

 

deanthebookkeeper's picture

Change of accountants needed?

deanthebookkeeper | | Permalink

This is not the first time JD wetherspoons have made errors this bad. When I worked as a manager for them years ago we were offered bonuses for finding potential sites but had to send our finding to a property firm Van De Berg

It is an indictment of our insane TAX system

androo235 | | Permalink

that it enables adults to earn their (often very good) livings with such socially and economically useless ponderings and deliberations as these.

Henry George - Progress and Poverty. I like Steve Keen's Debunking Economic's too.

And. Not only accountants. Wetherspoon's (and other) managers spend time speculating and worrying whether they will be able to capitalise (ie put on their balance sheet) some spend and then write it off against profits over some years, or, whether they should just knock it off profit and loss this year. This trivial issue generates such hot-air, but, that's our (and everyone;s else's ...) neo-classical economics driven tax system.

Mason Gaffney - The Corruption of Economics - I like that too.