Are the best networkers extroverts? | AccountingWEB

Are the best networkers extroverts?

As I slumped in my chair, exhausted after another evening of ‘working the room’, I was pondering whether I am an extrovert or an introvert – and whether this had any relationship to my ability to be a good networker. Particularly as most accountants (but not all it has to be said) are introverts – does this mean that accountants are lousy networkers?

The thing is (and this annoys me) there is an industry pandering to the perception that introverts are shy, unconnected and get overwhelmed by meeting lots of people – and so need help to network. The industry also has the solution – lots of books, articles and products to help introverts feel happier about networking and ‘working the room’.

I have a number of problems with this perception. Firstly whether you are an introvert or an extrovert has NO bearing on whether you make a great networker. Yes, no bearing. Whether your natural preference – as defined by Jung - is for introversion or extroversion, this has no correlation with your ability to build and maintain relationships. While an introvert has a preference for a small circle of very close and deep friends, and extrovert has a preference for a larger circle of friends but less deep friendships. If the key to being a great networker is to have strong relationships with the people who can help your business or career, then I want to both an extrovert and an introvert.

Jung’s definition of extroversion is where people are energised by the company of other people. Introversion is the opposite – where people are energised by their own company. Jung did not say that introverts or extroverts have more or less social confidence, or that either is any better at growing mutually beneficial relationships. So why do people assume that extroverts will happily work a room and introverts hate working a room?

The other reason I get annoyed by this perception that introverts need help to work the room, is the assumption that to network you need to work the room. Not so. I am considered by many people to be a true connector (as defined by Gladwell in ‘the tipping point’) and someone with an amazing little black book of contacts.  100% of my new business comes to me from existing clients and my network, particularly a few key relationships. However, I very rarely work the room – and when I do, I find it very exhausting. I normally need an hour or so to myself to recharge after a few hours of ‘working the room’ with many people I don’t know. I now tend to use online tools and personal recommendations to find the right people for my business, rather than the random nature of working the room at a conference or mix and mingle type event. When I have identified a key relationship, I will then progress the relationship via 1-2-1 meetings.

What do you think, are extroverts better networkers than introverts?




Are the best networkers extroverts

Joe_Planys | | Permalink





/* Style Definitions */
{mso-style-name:"Table Normal";
mso-padding-alt:0cm 5.4pt 0cm 5.4pt;
mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman";
mso-bidi-font-family:"Times New Roman";

I really couldn't let this and some other blogs go without commenting.

There is a pernicious movement in the business world in the direction of 'networking' and 'social media marketing' which really does let businesses down badly with advice built on poor assumptions and constructs - that are much more in the in the interests of the 'guru's' than your business.

I notice in previous blogs - particularly what not to do on Linkedin - that there is an underlying presumption that you can't possibly appear as a salesperson - because that would be suspicious and dishonest. Well if you are not selling something what on earth are you doing? Exchanging pleasantries and chitter chatter with people you don't know - online and in stuffy events - because you just like to? To give something back to the community? Because you like sharing? What a pile of nonsense. Is this not significantly more underhand than telling people what you offer and asking if they want to buy it?

Frankly - I will be glad when all of this flim flam finally plays itself out - which it most certainly will - and proves to be out to be a waste of energy and time. The guru's are filling their boots at your expense and networking and social media marketing are not substitutes for selling. Mark my words - once people have had their fill of canapés and have worker their fingers to the bone on 'DigIt' - without closing a single deal - the 'guru's' will start to tell you that it doesn't really work like that - there's some other magical flim flam that might though. It's already started.

If you want my advice - lift the phone. Call a customer and make an appointment to go see them. It's more efficient and you don't have to skulk around networking events or SM sites for months trying to 'build relationships'.

- Joe

plummy1's picture

Are the best net-workers extroverts

plummy1 | | Permalink


Let me first say I have read Heather Townsend's book and I would recommend it to anyone who wants to improve their business networking both on and off line.

Firstly let me say I don't think there is any right or wrong approach to creating business relationships and I am sure that Joe's approach above works for him.

However I am in a partnership with a very extroverted salesman whilst I am an introverted procurement professional. Our business has been helped tremendously by the use of on-line and of line networking. I am happier starting to form business relationships on-line and working towards a meeting while my business partner likes nothing more than meeting a large room of complete strangers and visibly comes alive when he does.

The only thing I would say to Joe is try and cold call some professional services companies such as accountants and solicitors and try and get a meeting with them but you may be surprised by your lack of success. I'm sure cold calling does work in some cases but it is not for everybody and does not work within every industry,


Add comment
Log in or register to post comments
This blog

I help professionals, mostly accountants and lawyers become the Go-To-Expert. After joining BDO LLP in 2004, I have now almost clocked up ten years working predominantly with accountants helping them achieve their career and business goals. Unusually for someone with an Engineering Degree, I accidentally became a writer and used my knowledge on social media to write the current best-selling and award-winning book on networking, The FT Guide To Business Networking. (over 100 five star reviews on amazon) In 2012, the book I always wanted to write, 'How to make partner and still have a life' was published. In March 2014, my latest book, 'The Go-To-Expert: How to build your reputation, differentiate yourself from the competition and win business' was published. People frequently talk about me as someone who really knows her stuff – which may be the reason I have, over the last decade, worked with over 300 partners, coached and trained over 2000 professionals at every level of the UK’s most ambitious professional practices. 

I am honoured to have been asked to judge the British Accountancy Awards in 2011 and 2012. I am a member of the Accountant's Club Global Advisory Panel, and write regularly on practice management issues for CCH.

Myself, and Jon (my co-director) are approved Growth Accelerator Coaches. This means that we can if you are eligible, through the Growth Accelerator scheme, help you get some coaching funded by the scheme. Click here for more details to see whether you are eligible for the scheme.

Read how we have helped one of our accountancy clients access Growth Accelerator funding to grow their turnover by nearly 50% and profits by over 200%

The types of work I am currently helping my small professional practice clients with, includes:

1) Helping a £2m t/o practice grow to £4m by restructuring the firm and helping the management team step up 

2) Working with a £1m t/o practice to grow to £2m by generating more leads, and getting more work from existing clients

3) Enabling a £300k t/o practice grow to £1m by helping it sort out it's profitability by adding in efficient systems and processes, and increasing the quality of the  lead generation by marketing to a niche

4) Facilitating the growth of a one man band practice into a 3 person practice by helping increase the lead generation and conversion rate of leads, plus keeping the practice owner accountable to his goals.

The Excedia Group was founded by myself and Jon Baker to bring clarity, perspective and knowledge to help our clients achieve their business goals. We specialise in working with highly technical individuals, typically lawyers and accountants, helping them to get out of their comfort zone and build a profitable and sustainable client portfolio whilst handling the challenges of leading a business. 

My work splits into about 50% Executive & Business Coaching with Partners & potential partners, with the rest split between training, consultancy and writing.

My articles & quotes regularly appear in the press, e.g. FT, Guardian, Accountancy Age, Accounting Today, Economia, ACCA's publications. I regularly blog at Partnership Potentialventure-NowJoined up networking and How to make partner.

To book me for a speaking engagement please contact my PR Agency, Meerkat PR, on 020 8563 0182, and ask for David Stoch. For any other work related enquiries, please contact me directly.

My clients have included: Deloitte LLP, KPMG LLP, BDO LLP, Haines Watts, MSI Global Alliance, UK200 group, Macintyre Hudson LLP amongst others.