Simon Sweetman was an inspector of taxes for 18 years. He left the Inland Revenue in 1989 to join Chartered Accountants Scrutton Goodchild & Sanderson, later part of Scrutton Bland, where he was successively a senior manager and later a partner. He has been an independent consultant since 2001. He is a member of the tax policy unit of the Federation of Small Businesses and the small business working group of the Chartered Institute of Taxation. He is also on the tax law review committee of the Institute for Fiscal Studies and is currently chair of the Working Together group for the Suffolk and North Essex area.
Celebrity tax exile: More money than sense
Tracey Emin was recently added to the list of well known figures reportedly leaving Britain for tax reasons. ‘Good riddance’, says Simon Sweetman.
Tracey Emin, queen of Britart, is considering moving to France for tax reasons. According to The Times: “She joins a threatened exodus by celebrities, footballers and hedge fund bosses in search of less onerous tax regimes”. When drawing up a list of those who would not be missed, most people in this country would probably have produced something very similar.
For her next project, Emin will be offering to design and make personalised neon signs for up to 10 buyers, each of whom is willing to pay £65,000.
Any individual wanting a neon sign must fill in a form with 15 questions so that it can be customised. Questions will include your favourite colour and poem, and some more personal ones such as whether you believe in God or talk while making love (or perhaps whether you talk to God or believe in the power of love).
I suspect that whatever your views about Tracey Emin, it is hard not to feel that anyone forking out for this has so much surplus cash that they ought to be paying more tax themselves (or indeed that we ought to have their names and addresses).
Bonjour taxman
Ms Emin already has a house in France and clearly makes well over £150,000 a year (for activities that might not go down too well with most of the taxpaying public), so I suspect she will find it hard to garner too much sympathy for her plight. But would the move make sense (ignoring the possibility that, as so often with these declarations, it’s just another piece of publicity)? Several of the entrepreneurs reported to be ‘suffering’ under the current regime don’t actually seem to have left the country.
If one were planning to go somewhere and not pay very much in tax, it is clear that France would not be top of the list. The French tax system is bureaucratic in the extreme; you have complications with local taxes, and in general the French are more heavily taxed than the British, so presumably Ms Emin had not talked to her tax adviser before shooting her mouth off.
In some circles people seem to believe that France is easier because of the deal that was set up with the Rolling Stones - but that was 30 years ago. There may be good reasons for living in France (like the cheese counters in hypermarkets) but I don’t think tax is one of them.
In the meantime if anyone would like a copy of this article handwritten on vellum, it’s yours for £10,000 - what a snip!
Sweetman's Lost the plot
So Sweetman does not like Tracy Emin. Thats irrelevant.
What is relevant is celebrities leaving the UK. THAT is BAD NEWS. It means less tax income at a time when the country needs every penny. Celebrities pay tax if they are living here, Income Tax, VAT, Excise duty. They generate Foreign Currency into UK, They may even encorage fans to visit UK.
So if our tax system needs to encourage high earners to stay or move in, then we must do it. Otherwise the Irish, French or whatever will do it. Already Ireland encourages writers with a low/zero tax rate.
Wake up Britain.
The rich leaving the country is always a good thing.
Large disparities of wealth are always a bad thing for a society. See http://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/docs/inequality.pdf
I once read an article in Accountancy magazine suggesting a tax on ostentatious displays of wealth, due to their socially divisive effect. No rich, no ostentatious displays of wealth.
@philmoul
I take your point but how can the UK compete with say Monaco when it comes to cheap tax regimes.
As it is, someone like Philip Green can live offshore, earn shedloads from running businesses over here, and zip back to Monaco without paying anything back to the UK economy
No offence Phil G if you're reading this, you're only playing the rules. Say hello to Kate Moss for us.
Kate Moss?
Do your clients know you have such appalling judgement?
Kate Moss
Sorry I should have made it clear that Ms Moss would not be first choice for my polite greetings.
Mr Green (God bless all who work for him) tends not to hang out with, say, Julia Bradbury, Maria Sharapova, my wife's sister, Emily Watson etc.
(Only kidding my wife doesn't have a sister)













All in favour of celebs leaving the UK
But why oh why do we let them back in again?
Topping my list of 'celebs to go' would be Gordon Ramsay but I'm sure you lot have some nominations. No politicians please, that's way too easy. Except Lembit Opik of course.