The Philip Hammond Appreciation Society’s sole paid-up member

Banana skin
istock_hatman12-banna_skin
Imprudent Accountant
Partner
An unnamed firm
Columnist
Share this content

I am proud to declare myself as a fully paid-up member of the Philip Hammond Appreciation Society.

Indeed, I have already ordered my copy of the great man’s memoirs, which might be published far sooner than anyone had expected on the basis that very soon he could have more writing time on his hands than had seemed likely last Wednesday morning.

Only when the man who has somehow got a reputation as a martyr to the spreadsheet dishes the dirt will we get the full story of how he managed to break a Tory manifesto pledge and a week later was obliged to do a U-turn on his banana skin.

There are so many questions that need to be answered.

  1. Was Philip Hammond aware of the election manifesto pledge when he stood up to address the country?
  2. Did Theresa May know that she was breaking a manifesto pledge?
  3. Was Theresa May told about Philip Hammond’s plans in this area in advance?
  4. Did either of them understand the consequences of what the Government was doing by increasing NIC for the self-employed?

As I say, the truth is unlikely to emerge while Mr Hammond is in office and quite possibly we will have to wait a few years after his departure to get the answers to these four questions.

Looking forward now, the Government is in a real bind. In the short term, it has a massive funding gap at a time when the economy seems to be in real trouble with the pound collapsing and some major businesses beginning to consider relocation to the European mainland.

In the longer term, the Chancellor of the Exchequer (whoever he or she may be through the remainder of this Parliament but let’s use the name Philip Hammond) has very few means of raising taxes at a time when economic uncertainty is likely to leave us all in a parlous state.

I think I can safely suggest that Mr Hammond will not consider increasing National Insurance Contributions, income tax or VAT, all of which were guaranteed to be outside his remit in the party’s manifesto, since any change in these areas will cause furore in the press, not to mention transport caffs (okay and in accountants’ offices) up and down the country.

As the party that delights in reducing corporation tax and inheritance tax, those also seem to be off-limits. What is left?

Having offended the white van man last week, taxes around vehicles are probably not going to be on the agenda either. Are we going to see insurance premium tax hiked up to 100% or a new windfall on banks? Bearing in mind both of these industries might be in the vanguard when the rush to Europe starts, such changes could be counter-productive.

This will be a real dilemma, leading to cuts to all kinds of public expenditure over the next few years unless Mr Hammond has the nous to invent a new tax or rebrand an old one to get around the manifesto pledge.

We live in interesting times.

Replies

Please login or register to join the discussion.

16th Mar 2017 12:11

Did Gauke put that banana peel there?
That stupid anti-selfemployed rhethoric has his fingerprints all over it.

Thanks (1)
avatar
16th Mar 2017 15:32

It does seem weird as Hammy stood up and said he was increasing NIC to get a bit more parity between PAYE and the Self-employed. So obviously they talked about it. He also said "I make no apologise" which indicates they new it was wrong. Maybe it was one of those "let's throw it on the fire and see what happens". I don't see how TM can be upset as she was nodding approval all through his speech.

Thanks (1)
avatar
17th Mar 2017 11:31

With the post referendum boom continuing amongst a seemingly endless flurry of announcements of new UK investments there will be no need for new taxes just lower rates on the existing ones.
As the EU implodes with the loss of its second largest contributor and EU businesses fear the loss of their UK market sterling's devaluation will continue to attract more businesses to the UK.

Thanks (0)
to Knight Rider
17th Mar 2017 11:52

Can I have whatever you're taking? Don't know what it is but it sounds awesome.

Thanks (1)
avatar
17th Mar 2017 13:01

Coffee and cake. Perhaps the author of this blog should have some too. Philip Hammond made a mistake, admitted it and performed a U turn. The amount involved is tiny, a mere rounding error in forecasting terms.
With all the good economic news pouring in daily we really should be optimistic and upbeat not thinking about unnecessary new taxes.

Thanks (0)