P11Ds and HMRC

Thanks Marion as you say, bit of a faff, but well done on solving the connundrum.

What I wanted to post was:

Has anyone else had any problems linked to P11ds and P46 (Car) forms.

we have the employee of a client who gave up her company car 11/12, we sent the P11d electronically, and then later the P46 car. code duly amended, then inexplicably re-amended to include the car again.

Poor employee spent 20 frustraing minutes trying to sort it only to be told 2 P11ds had been submitted (they hadn't and even if they had how would it affect anything 11/12?).

Same employer diffeent employee leaves job, P46 car sent in, HMRC write back saying we've never told them of the existence of that particular car. Seem to ignore the P46 Car sent June 09 and the two years P11ds that followed. Result very unhappy employer and equally unhappy employees.

I presume it is the usual reason that paper P46 cars go in the bin, and the electronic versions don't  work unless everything has always been filed electronically and input exactly at HMRC end.