Share this content
0
455

Can you claim entrepreneurs relief for companys

Company selling shares it owns in another company

Didn't find your answer?

Search AccountingWEB

Can a company who owns shares in another company claim entrepreneurs relief - my client is insisting that we can but looking at the wording online this only applies to individuals?

Replies

Please login or register to join the discussion.

avatar
By pfluge
16th May 2019 08:50

I should of added that this company who owns the shares sold the shares to another company (so company to company)

Thanks (0)
16th May 2019 08:56

Entrepreneurs relief is a CGT relief.
Companies don't pay CGT.
No tax, no relief.

Thanks (0)
to Tim Vane
16th May 2019 09:05

Tim Vane wrote:

Entrepreneurs relief is a CGT relief.
Companies don't pay CGT.
No tax, no relief.

Yes - tell your client that he doesn't get Entrepreneur's Relief but the upside is that there's no CGT.

Thanks (0)
avatar
to Tim Vane
16th May 2019 09:19

Tim Vane wrote:

Entrepreneurs relief is a CGT relief.
Companies don't pay CGT.
No tax, no relief.

What's "a CGT relief"? Why use terms that don't exist in law to answer a question that, for once, makes reference to the law?

The OP is spot on - ER, per legislation, does not apply because it's a relief for individuals (and Trustees by extension); the legislation does not say it's "a CGT relief".

Thanks (0)
to Tax Dragon
16th May 2019 10:05

That's a bit pedantic, isn't it? It's a relief defined in the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act as giving a lower rate of capital gains tax, to say that's fundamentally different to calling it a CGT relief is a bit of a stretch, no?

Thanks (0)
avatar
to Duggimon
16th May 2019 10:15

Not really. It's a relief provided under TCGA. TCGA applies to companies.

You should be pointing out the pedantry in replies like "it's a CGT relief, companies don't pay CGT".

Thanks (0)
to Tax Dragon
16th May 2019 11:16

No, I mean it literally says in the first line of the bit of legislation in which it's defined "This Chapter provides for a lower rate of capital gains tax in respect of qualifying business disposals (to be known as “entrepreneurs’ relief”)." and you're asserting that and "CGT relief" are two different things.

I don't think it's pedantic to point out Entrepreneurs Relief doesn't apply to companies because it relates to a tax that doesn't apply to companies. Indeed it's just answering the original question.

Thanks (0)
avatar
to Duggimon
16th May 2019 11:46

I don't feel strongly enough to disagree.

I do think that Tim's oft-repeated observation that "companies don't pay CGT", whilst correct, is - maybe just occasionally - intended to misguide, rather than to assist. (Lion's contribution was equally unhelpful.) As you (and Tim) well know, TCGA does apply to companies. And it's not s169H(1) that stops ER applying to companies.

[Being a natural born pedant, though, what does s169H(1) actually mean? Read it again, carefully. (I know it's two half sentences pushed together, due to the history of the relief, but, really, isn't it now a nonsense? Just as well it doesn't do anything!)]

Thanks (0)
avatar
By CTA
to Tim Vane
16th May 2019 12:14

To continue the pedantry, the statement "Companies don't pay CGT" is also incorrect.

Thanks (2)
to CTA
16th May 2019 12:25

I'm more likely to pick up on "companys" as the plural of "company".

Thanks (0)
avatar
to CTA
16th May 2019 12:33

Moving forward, that statement is correct.

Thanks (0)
to CTA
16th May 2019 12:52

You're going to have to explain that one. It might be misleading by glossing over the equivalent for companies, but it's definitely not wrong.

TCGA applies to companies, CGT does not.

Thanks (0)
avatar
to Duggimon
16th May 2019 12:58

CGT applies to non-resident companies (except in relation to assets used for the purposes of a trade carried on through a UK permanent establishment) up to 2018/19.

Non-resident companies were liable to CGT on gains on UK residential property up to 2018/19. From 2019/20 they are liable to corporation tax on their chargeable gains on UK real property interests (including shares in other companies that have such interests).

Thanks (0)
to Vile Nortin Naipaan
16th May 2019 13:02

Likewise for UK companies with ATED-related gains

Thanks (0)
avatar
to Wilson Philips
16th May 2019 13:36

Dammit - turns out I'm not pedantic enough!! :-)

(Sorry, that was meant as a reply to CTA.)

Thanks (0)
avatar
16th May 2019 08:57

Shouldn't you be looking at the possibility of the substantial shareholding exemption?

Thanks (0)
By DJKL
to Wanderer
16th May 2019 15:41
Thanks (0)
avatar
16th May 2019 12:33

OP. Yes. Claim what you like.

Thanks (0)
Share this content