Am I alone in thinking that Company car advice to owner directors is a minefield and getting worse? Rules change regularly and the compounded options seem to make it impossible to cover all bases with just some of the things (incomplete list) to consider being:
- VAT
- BIK
- CA's
- Lease v hire v HP, Electric v hybrid v petrol/diesel
- Company owned v director owned
- Company profitability/losses
- Alternative methods of director remuneration
- Personal income tax rates
- Commercial deals v personal deals
- Balloon payment level
- Lease term (years)
- Fleet deals
- Make and Model
- CO2
- Car v Van
- Electric range
I always struggle to provide company car advice on the occasional times that I am asked and I always spend many hours to ensure that my knowledge is right up to date and that I have covered as many matters as I possibly can. To the best of my belief I do a go job but always go over an acceptable budget and charge the client far less than the value of my time. I think clients perceive the advice to be far easier to give than it actually is and this is reflected in my reluctance to charge very much for the advice.
Any template reply goes out of date and new rules are difficult to keep up to date with. Ideally, I would outsource this advice but cannot find a suitable provider. An up-to-date template or booklet would be great but I cannot find a suitable white label product.
How do you other accountants (qualified or unqualified) manage to deal with this type of advice when you only provide it on an occasional basis?
Replies (25)
Please login or register to join the discussion.
I tell 'em to get a much nicer 2-3 year old car in their own name as it will work out much better value.
But if its electric its probably worth it, but only if they were about to spend £30-50k on a new car anyway, not because the shiny thing has a tax break.
The comps are always a pain to explain to the client and its often marginal or we wouldn't be doing 'em.
But if its electric its probably worth it, but only if they were about to spend £30-50k on a new car anyway, not because the shiny thing has a tax break.
Do good tax breaks stop you in a straight line?
ireallyshouldknowthisbut wrote:
But if its electric its probably worth it, but only if they were about to spend £30-50k on a new car anyway, not because the shiny thing has a tax break.
Do good tax breaks stop you in a straight line?
No, but a dead battery will.
At present I am inclined to say how difficult it is, but... an electric car with zero% BIK, and usually giving 100% relief for the company seems a good deal for now.
Otherwise get a van. Who wouldn't love a van. Just so handy for carrying stuff/people (obviously primarily loads, not people, by design).
Mostly clients can be encouraged to tell you what the choice is between, so that narrows down the consideration somewhat.
No hope of producing complete advice, given the tax rules and the unknowns.
We'll all be cycling soon anyway if the clowns in the councils get their way!!
How cycle lanes will cure the pandemic is a mystery to my simple brain...
The main road into Manchester City centre from the south is 2 lanes and can on a bad day be a 3 mile crawling queue. One if the 2 lanes has now been coned off for cyclists since May. Since then, I’ve seen 24 cyclists using it. Seems a fair split of the road, especially as they pay road tax ...
"especially as they pay road tax ..."
*sigh*
I pay road tax on two cars. I also cycle.
Virtually all cyclists also drive so your local councils decisions aside, poor argument against the evil cyclists, coming over here, not burning any fossil fuels, getting there quicker than you AND reducing their waistlines. Utter utter utter selfish so and so's
A fair few could take a cycle safety test for a start; across the pavements, ignore the colour of the lights, drive up the inside on one's blindspot etc.
I have no issue with cycling per se but some of the idiots allowed to be in charge of a bicycle now need policed- number plates on bikes , cameras and fixed penalties is where we likely now need to head.
But the government encouraged people to cycle at a time when they couldn't take a safety course if they wanted to due to social distancing!! I confess that I haven't ever taken one and now cycle regularly but given that I took a driving test 27 years ago and a motorcycle test 7 years ago, I feel that I am probably adequately au fait with the laws of the road - and riding a motorbike has taught me to expect more or less anything from every road user.
My bicycle is insured and my car and motorbike are taxed and insured. I'm sure when people see me on my bicycle they will still assume that I'm a lycra lout and decide that I should be paying RFL though.
When asked I simply say “if it’s 100% electric, sure. If it’s not, dont”.
Job done. None of my clients have company cars. I don’t submit a single P11D.
. I don’t submit a single P11D.*
* Not entirely true, Mrs ALISK & I have P11Ds for health insurance.
What about overdrawn DLAs and those who have put through personal tax return fees?
I answer company car queries in exactly the same way as you (and hope they won’t ask for a calculation).
Personal tax returns are included 'free' on my ltd co engagement letters. Clients are aware of the reality & reason for that.
DLAs stay below the interest threshold . Normally. Somehow.
Personal tax returns are included 'free' on my ltd co engagement letters. Clients are aware of the reality & reason for that.
DLAs stay below the interest threshold . Normally. Somehow.
Pretty much my line too. I have a client who bought a beautiful (OK, I'm a petrol head) Tesla for around £93k and have a tiny BIK. If I could afford a Tesla as a toy then I might do likewise.
I tell them straight away that there are so many variables that it's impossible to say exactly, but as a general rule of thumb it's not worth having a company car unless you are buying brand new and doing a lot of business miles with a biggish engine. Otherwise, buy the car yourself and claim mileage.
Then the new EV regime complicated that somewhat **rolls eyes**
To be helpful, I always add - let me know specific details when you have a better idea of what vehicle you want and I will be able to tell you the tax consequences. Most owner directors choose the vehicle they want and then need the most tax efficient way of handling that vehicle, rather than choosing a vehicle to fit a particular tax break. Basically, they need to narrow it down and then you can steer them away from the pitfalls (like believing everything the salesman told them about how they can claim all the VAT back).