Share this content

Company incorporation - share structure

2 shareholders - A + B shares - goodwill attached to B shares and different split. Workable?

Didn't find your answer?

2 people looking to set up a company.  They have agreed to split profits 50/50 but goodwill of the company (if successful) to be split 60/40.

Is there an issue with setting a company up as:

A shares - split 50/50 - full rights to voting, dividends and rights to capital (excluding proceeds from sale of goodwill or if trade not sold excluding excess of stated balance sheet reserves)

B shares - split 60/40 - no rights other than right to capital in excess of the balance sheet reserves or proceeds from sale of goodwill

Thanks in advance for any assistance

Replies (4)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

By trucker
09th Jul 2020 21:16

Or could you simply say rights to capital for both class of shares as referenced in the shareholders agreement

Thanks (0)
By Paul Crowley
10th Jul 2020 09:19

Recipe for future disputes when they fall out. Would legal people interpret the agreement the way they now consider the way it is to be interpreted.

Thanks (0)
By paul.benny
10th Jul 2020 13:24

The concept is fundamentally flawed because there can never (barring acquisitions) be any goodwill in the company's accounts. You cannot recognise internally-generated goodwill.

If the owners subsequently sell the company, there is no "goodwill" as such - the buyer may pay a premium over net asset value; if they prepare group accounts, that would be recognised in the *buyer's* group accounts

If instead of selling the company, they were to sell the trade and assets for more than net asset value, the company would show a profit, but again, no goodwill.

Thanks (0)
By lionofludesch
10th Jul 2020 13:46

They need to rethink this. The best I can come up with is for them to hold shares 50/50 and one of them has a right to buy 20% of the other's holding (ie 10% of the total) for a nominal sum should some specific event take place, like a sale of the company.

It's fraught with dangers and it isn't anything I'd recommend without a boatload of caveats, which would mainly consist of "I told you it was a bad idea but you still did it".

Thanks (0)
Share this content

Related posts