Farmer's averaging

Forgive the daft question

Didn't find your answer?

Afternoon campers,

Quick question regarding averaging. Farmer made a £70k loss in 2023/24 but £15k profits in preceeding four years. It is my understanding that this gets my average profit for all five years up to and including 2023/24 to £12k PLUS I get to carry forward my £70k losses from 2023/24.

IRIS Elements is trying to force me to set part of my £70k losses against the £12k from 2023/24. This is making me doubt my interpretation of HS224 which appears to support my view.

Opinions welcomed please!

Replies (6)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

avatar
By Paul Crowley
09th Jul 2024 15:53

I currently do not trust IRIS for anything with a change in it.
The partnership that had both a change of partners and two accounting dates in is producing rubbish on all the partners in personal tax.
To make it right, I need to overwrite every entry, including overlap.

No faith in the software unless it is very very simple stuff.

Thanks (0)
Caroline
By accountantccole
10th Jul 2024 07:53
Thanks (0)
Replying to accountantccole:
avatar
By bettybobbymeggie
10th Jul 2024 08:13

Thanks for your reply. I did read this but frustratingly their example is where the loss happened before the profit whereas mine is the other way around. That said, HS224's example 2 is as follows:

Example 2 — Two Year Averaging
Year - 2021 to 2022 loss of £20,000
Year - 2020 to 2021 profit of £32,000

2020 to 2021 profit is increased from £0 to £16,000 and this increase of £16,000 must be entered in box 72 on page SEF 4. The loss of £20,000 should be entered in box 77.

This is my scenario exactly but I am doubting myself because IRIS says I need to use the £20k loss against the £16k averaging adjustment in 2021/22.

Thanks (0)
paddle steamer
By DJKL
10th Jul 2024 09:03

(5)If the taxpayer makes a loss in the qualifying trade, profession or vocation in a tax year, the relevant profits of the tax year for the purposes of this Chapter are nil.

221(5)

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2005/5/section/221

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Ardeninian
10th Jul 2024 11:30

You are right and IRIS is wrong. s84 ITA (carry forward loss relief for the loss arising in 2023/24) is deducted from the profits of the next tax year first, not the current tax year. So you are under no obligation to use the losses against the 2023/24 adjusted profit, as the working sheet for SA103 should confirm

Thanks (1)
avatar
By bettybobbymeggie
11th Jul 2024 15:42

Thanks for the replies. Happily IRIS support came back to me and suggested I clear the cache - highly likely to fix [***]ty software.

Thanks (0)