# Holiday Goggles over dividends?

Holiday Goggles over dividends?

• ### VAT treatment for purchase of "SaaS" products

So I return from holiday to a dead computer (now revived through a sort of computer heart and lung machine) then take a look at the dividend "fact"sheet produced by HMRC.  Have they made an error in Example 3 in their explanation, though not in their liability?

Example 3 says this:

“I have a non-dividend income of £6,500, and a dividend income of £12,000 from shares outside of an ISA”

"With a Personal Allowance of £11,000, £7,500 of the dividends are under the threshold for tax. A further £5,000 comes within the Dividend Allowance, leaving tax to pay at Basic Rate (7.5%) on £2,500."

Now when I was at school £7,500 plus £5,000 plus £2,500 was £15,000 not £12,000

The total income is clearly £18,500 and after the deduction of the personal allowance of £11,000 it leaves £7,500 within the charge to tax.  Dividends are the top slice of income so all of the £7,500 is dividend income.  £5,000 of this is charged at the nil rate (the dividend "allowance") and that leaves £2,500 to be charged at 7.5%.  Surely it should say "with a personal allowance of £11,000, £5,500 of the dividends are under the threshold for tax" - shouldn't it?

### Replies (4)

By Steve Kesby
25th Aug 2015 13:09

Surely...

... it should say "£4,500 of the dividends are under the threshold for tax". :)

The £7,500 is, of course the amount of dividends that are taxable before the dividend allowance is deducted. All of the other numbers appear to be correct.

Thanks (0)
By Tonykelly
25th Aug 2015 12:30

I would say £4,500

I would say £4,500 are under threshold for tax.

Non-dividend income of £6500 plus £4500 gives you your personal allowance of £11,000.

Leaving £7,500 dividend income above allowance.

£5000 tax free

£2500 at 7.5%

Thanks (0)
By Triggle
25th Aug 2015 13:38

It should say:

"With a Personal Allowance of £11,000, £7,500 of the dividends are over the threshold for tax. A further £5,000 comes within the Dividend Allowance, leaving tax to pay at Basic Rate (7.5%) on £2,500."

We should all click on the "Is anything wrong with this page" link at the bottom of the page

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/dividend-allowance-factsheet/dividend-allowance-factsheet

and be completely ignored by HMRC.

Thanks (0)
By Paul Soper
25th Aug 2015 15:24

Thanks all

Yes it should be £4,500 - the effects of returning from Greece to London temperatures that are normal for a Shetland summer (I know because I was in Shetland a couple of years back) are clearly still being felt!  Triggle is probably closest to what they were trying to say but this is hardly clarification is it?

Thanks (0)