Share this content

Payroll software with payroll giving

Looking for cheap and simple stand-alone payroll software which can handle payroll giving

Didn't find your answer?

We use a combined HR and Payroll solution and while we're fairly happy with the HR side the Payroll function just doesn't seem to function very well. I'm looking to switch us over to something cheap and cheerful like The Payroll Site but we've also been trying to get set up with Payroll Giving and The Payroll Site can't handle Payroll Giving or submission of P11Ds.

Am I dreaming too big by expecting any of the small £2-3 per user solutions to handle Payroll Giving and P11D submission? We have under 30 employees so it would be hard to justify moving over to a big fixed-price solution and I'm not keen to go back to passing spreadsheets back and forth by email to deal with a bureau.

Replies (8)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

avatar
By Wanderer
25th Jan 2022 17:03

Moneysoft mentions payroll giving on this page:-
https://moneysoft.co.uk/support/starting-mid-way-through-the-year/
so I'd assume it can cope.

Thanks (1)
avatar
By TheNovice
25th Jan 2022 19:41

I suggest Brightpay, can't stress how simple it is to use and how feature rich it is. It also does payroll giving.

They seem to have a guide for most things on their website and their support is also good/responsive.

And no, I don't work there.

Thanks (2)
avatar
By Hugo Fair
25th Jan 2022 19:42

I'd be surprised if most Payroll packages didn't support Payroll Giving - it's not exactly a newly emerged facility. Now if you wanted support for Payday Loans. for instance, or other things at various stages of being 'on the horizon' - then that'd be a different matter.

P11D submissions are however entirely dependent on what you're expecting.
Solutions out there can be as simple as picking up figures that you first have to type in for onwards submission to HMRC (and hopefully producing completed forms for employees - whether on paper, PDF or something else).
Or as all encompassing as guiding you to the correct values through integration with worksheets with embedded rules.
But (cheeky question) why aren't you dealing with BiKs via in-year payrolling and so avoiding the need for P11Ds?

Anyway, other features & price constraints are likely to be more important to you than these two facets ... so if I were you I'd concentrate on making sure the prime decision factors have first been agreed - and then approach all the usual suspects (or at least check out their websites) to see whether your preferred choices support your extra needs.

Thanks (1)
ALISK
By atleastisoundknowledgable...
25th Jan 2022 23:33

Moneysoft

Thanks (1)
avatar
By mbee1
26th Jan 2022 14:13

Brightpay

Thanks (1)
avatar
By suepg
26th Jan 2022 14:22

Moneysoft

Thanks (1)
avatar
By optima
27th Jan 2022 10:52

Brightpay

Thanks (0)
me.jpg
By clark.hall
03rd Feb 2022 09:40

Moneysoft and BrightPay are those most frequently recommended on here. Having tried them both my vote lies with BrightPay for its ease of use while incorporating all payroll funtions (inc Payroll Giving and P11D's). Good value, better UI and more modern solutions overall.

Thanks (0)
Share this content