Share this content

Reporting from 3 separate ERP systems

Internal report generation from 3 separate ERP systems, regionally/globally

Didn't find your answer?

Hi all,

I would like a little advice on how I can report various types of information from 3 separate ERP systems. I work for a company which has three different ERP systems which process data for three associated entities in three different geographic locations. The three different entities share a management team and operate economically like one unit. It would be ideal to be able to report summary and detailed information globally and regionally for these entities, however, I am unsure how I can achieve this in a cost effective way as the three different ERP systems are very different in nature. The systems are Sage 200, Xero and Quickbooks desktop version.

ODBC reporting: Initially, I was thinking I could set up ODBC links for each ERP system, then output whatever data is required onto a spreadsheet based report. However, I have been advised by a colleague that this is not possible as Quickbooks is not ideal for ODBC reporting. Is this correct, or is there another cost effective or better way to achieve what I am looking for? I'd like a bit of pointing me in the right direction towards best practice from this website, so any advice, even if very general, would be very appreciated.

Thanks in advance.


Replies (4)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

By paulwakefield1
28th May 2020 08:06

How often do you want to report? If periodically, then at the lowest level, csv exports from the 3 systems and using Excel and Power Query (aka Get and Transform) would be an effective, quick and cheap solution. And easy to maintain.

I have not used ODBC with Quickbooks but I had understood that there is an ODBC driver available for it.

If you can interrogate the various databases directly via ODBC, I would still use Power Query (and/or Power Pivot if necessary although that involves a steeper learning curve) to pull together the data into a consistent consolidated format from which you can generate your reports and dashboards.

Thanks (0)
Routemaster image
By tom123
28th May 2020 08:20

I would persevere with ODBC if you can - I really couldn't do my work without all my queries. Plus the ability to refresh instantly as you are working through the month end.

I use Sage 200,

Even if you get 2 out of three to ODBC, and then combine with a csv that would work.

Thanks (0)
A Putey FACA
By Arthur Putey
28th May 2020 15:36

No ODBC for Xero either. You don't mention how it is done at the moment or whether the legal entities, base currencies or charts of accounts are different, but I would try and create an identically formatted report in each system then export it to Excel, based on the TB or P&L and BS. You could look at 3rd party reporting tools to manage the actual reporting and analysis but it depends what level of detail and complexity is needed.

Thanks (0)
Routemaster image
By tom123
28th May 2020 15:41

It is a shame you haven't managed to migrate some of these systems together - is there a reason why you are not going down that path?

Thanks (0)
Share this content

Related posts