I read the following forum and I'm very happy with it. Except for a few pinned threads it's in latest comment order. There's an edit button with the comment. There are 20 comments per page and the comment box is at the bottom of each page but you can reply to any comment which is a bit like what AccountingWeb has but it doesn't reply on a slight indent. There's no big blobs, jumping around or painful author information or categorisation - you can use a simple categorisation if you want but you can ignore it. What do you think?