Share this content

Choosing your accountant, qualified or not............

5th Jun 2012
Share this content

Me, and my girlfriend, are both accountants. I know, imagine the parties. I'm an ACA; my better, prettier looking half is an ACCA. Of course, I joke about the solutions to most answers being in my books rather than hers, but at the end of the day, it’s just banter (kind of).

It got me thinking about whether or not it actually matters what qualification your accountant holds, or, if it even matters whether or not they are qualified at all.

My conclusion, probably surprisingly, is that it doesn't matter at all. Its all about substance over form.

I know plenty of people who carry out the functions of an accountant, who are not qualified but have many years of experience and provide a perfectly good service to their clients. Conversely, I know plenty of other qualified accounts who I wouldn’t trust with bank account reconciliations.

Ultimately, directors of limited company, partners and sole traders are all responsible for the information they file with companies house and HMRC, not their respective accountants. If your accountant makes a mistake you can of course seek compensation. However, the fines and penalty letters will always arrive on your doorstep, eventually.

Choosing your accountant (qualified or not) is a personal choice. You disclose enormous amounts of confidential information to your accountant so it’s not only important to get on with them, but trust them too.

Therefore it’s important to check a few items before proceeding;

· Check to see if your accountant has indemnity insurance. Do they offer fee insurance should you be the subject of a HMRC enquiry (which is softer way of saying tax investigation).

· Ask if they a member of any professional accounting bodies; members of such bodies need to complete at least three year’s work experience and a series of examinations. In addition each member must maintain their knowledge each year and declare that they have done so. The main practice accounting bodies (there are of course others) in England are;

§ The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (

§ The Association of Chartered and Certified Accountants (

· Check their experience and if at all possible request some client references.

· Request a draft engagement letter to ensure that the services you have asked for are covered as well as the fee terms. It helps protect you should services not be carried out as expected.

· See what type of clients they already act for. Some specialise in certain fields, some are more general. It’s not uncommon for whole departments in accountancy firms to leave and start their own practice. If possible, ask for a client reference.

· Try to meet the people, who will actually be carrying out the work. It may not be who you have initially been talking to.

It’s important for me to re-iterate that, although I’ve stated it doesn’t matter if your accountant is qualified of not, you are responsible for the information you file.

I have heard quotes and expressions similar to “I like my accountant, he asks no questions”. If this is the case, be prepared to deal with HMRC when they come knocking because I doubt that accountant will be fighting your corner when the fines and interest come rolling in. Saving tax is great, simply deferring tax is not so great.


You might also be interested in

Replies (3)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

By MarionMorrison
05th Jun 2012 17:37

The cowboy says amen

One key question/corollary to the qualifications question is 'what part of your examinations and qualifications will help me with my problems here?'  For some people seeking someone to lash together some figures and a tax return, the best qualifications are experience.  But if you have a company where you need to give some thought to structure or more complex stuff then there are advantages.

Over and over again I like to tell people that they should only ever use an accountant who comes to them with a first or second hand recommendation.  

The other advice I give people who aren't my clients is that unless they're 100% delighted with the way things are working, that they should consider changing accountants every 5 years to get a fresh perspective.  Of course that assumes you can get a new firm that you like.  I don't actually give this advice to existing clients! 

Thanks (0)
By s.wardrop
06th Jun 2012 13:25

Main UK accounting practices

Did you mean in "England" cos otherwise there is no excuse for leaving out ICAS, it being the oldest and longest established.

Thanks (0)
Replying to lionofludesch:
By Howell James
06th Jun 2012 13:58

Changed to England

s.wardrop wrote:

Did you mean in "England" cos otherwise there is no excuse for leaving out ICAS, it being the oldest and longest established.

thanks s.wardop, apologies for any offence

Thanks (0)