VAT Consultant vatadvice.org
Columnist
Share this content

Inter-company arrangement

20th May 2019
VAT Consultant vatadvice.org
Columnist
Share this content

If you are involved in a number of associated companies, this First Tier decision is worth a read.

The underlying technical issue was to do with a Partial Exemption calculation, and input tax incurred in relation to one company’s investment property activities.

The decision is not helped by a non-sensical HMRC decision: “HMRC’s decision to disallow this claim was based on the belief that when companies with a common director supply services to each other there is not a vatable supply as the other company could have supplied the services itself.”

The decision refers to ‘dual capacity companies,’ which had a common sole director. The two companies had quite distinct but related activities. The director had no clear inter-company agreement. In hindsight a simple Heads of Terms agreement would have saved him the stress of enduring the appeal process!

http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKFTT/TC/2019/TC07033.html

Replies (2)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

By alan.rolfe
20th May 2019 12:38

Interesting case, Les.

We are starting to see more HMRC questions about inter-company management charges, despite the largely VAT-neutral impact. This may help confirm to the Revenue that the commercial reality of management charges is correct for VAT purposes, too.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Justin Bryant
21st May 2019 10:43

Compare & contrast the direct tax case in the link below where there was a written agreement yet taxpayer lost:

https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/tax/business-tax/directors-payment-as-co...

Thanks (0)