Save content
Have you found this content useful? Use the button above to save it to your profile.
An image depicting a price increase
istock_Fee-increase_Mary Ne

Price hike or pricing strategy? Accountants, where are you?

by

As many accountants review their fees, branding expert Phillipa Hayes explores whether price hikes are really the answer or if firms should take a different strategy.

14th Mar 2022
Save content
Have you found this content useful? Use the button above to save it to your profile.

Another year, another conversation around fees. It’s March and the age-old question has raised its ugly head over the last couple of months: “Do we raise our fees and if so, how do we broach this with our clients?”

Let’s not beat around the bush here, what you’re really asking is “Shall we mention the subject, and will they say no?”

Go onto any forum or social media channel at this time of year and you’ll find the full range of questions around fees: How do we do it? What do we say? How do you charge? By time or by project? Annual or monthly fees? Subscription model or not?  Rate of inflation increase or more? And so on and so forth.

These are thorny issues which, I imagine, don’t get easier over time.

The good news is that it seems that you’re not alone. This is clear from the increasing number of coaches and software packages helping you to set and discuss your fees.

Pricing comes but once a year

The idea that the fees conversation happens once a year only adds to the pressure but ask many accountants and they’ll agree that often they’re thinking “new fee, new year” themselves.

It seems logical, almost expected. If there is any good time to do it, then the new year seems to be the time. It’s a common approach although some do it by reference to the calendar year, the tax year or each client’s accounting year.

But what does this really say to your clients? To my mind it may confirm that some clients feel that their accountant services are just a commodity. And that’s not helpful to anyone. 

Price hike approach says commodity?

Whether we like talking about our fees or not, taking the simple price-hike approach leads to commodity conversations with our clients. It’s as simple as that. 

And if you tackle your fees like this, then you’re likely to struggle with the same perceptions. Whatever your approach, wouldn’t it be great if you could start to think about fees more strategically in 2022 and beyond? 

A way forward

There are many more experienced in the accounting industry than me who talk about fees, so let me frame it from a brand perspective, after all that’s where my specialism lies.

If you have a strong and inspiring brand, you’ll be able to charge more. It’s as simple as that. 

We all make decisions, we all buy, and we make these decisions not purely on need but on desire. 

But when talking about accounting you may think there’s nothing tangible to “sell”. I would argue that if you have a brand based on you and your team and you have defined how you deliver your own unique service then you have a brand. After all, we are all unique but it’s conveying that uniqueness in your brand which is the skill.

Having a brand begins a longer-term conversation about adding value to your clients: “What does our brand mean we can do? Can it sustain an additional service to add value?”

If you have a clear brand with a clear and well-defined offer you’ve got a head start.  Brand enables you to shape your service to your client for example your onboarding. How do you deliver the welcome? Is it a welcome pack, a brochure, a video or something else? It can also inform what you say in this welcome and how you say it.  This all adds to the perception of value.

Brand also gives you the confidence to structure and execute a well-defined and broader client journey outside the usual remit such as events and the like to keep the dialogue alive. Greater client experience, greater perceived value.

You can choose

Cut back to February, and the inevitable email arrived for me from my accountant.  The fee rise was expected, was minimal and offered me little more than before.  

I was told that I didn’t need anything else based on last year’s activities but if I wanted to discuss further, I could book a call.

With no conversation over the year and no official lines of communication there was nothing more to do and nothing really to say. 

So, I left it with the same service, slightly higher fee. And no perception of additional value.

But with the right brand thinking this could have been so different. Every business owner has the power to choose: price hike or pricing strategy.

Replies (18)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

Mark Lee headshot 2023
By Mark Lee
15th Mar 2022 10:50

Nicely written and argued Philippa. I have certainly seen accountants with a clear brand who then build, grow and develop their practices faster than those who mistakenly assume and operate as if they are 'just another accountant'.

Thanks (0)
Replying to bookmarklee:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
15th Mar 2022 14:19

Thanks Mark for your comment.

I think there are many accountants who also think it's marketing puff but as we become more digital and have a broader reach accountants can choose to focus on word of mouth and referral as before or add another dimension to their firm which will secure a more sustainable future

Thanks (0)
Replying to bookmarklee:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
15th Mar 2022 14:19

Thanks Mark for your comment.

I think there are many accountants who also think it's marketing puff but as we become more digital and have a broader reach accountants can choose to focus on word of mouth and referral as before or add another dimension to their firm which will secure a more sustainable future

Thanks (0)
avatar
By Crouchy
15th Mar 2022 13:18

you seem to grumble that your fees have gone up but service hasn't, perhaps your fee could stay the same and you could have a reduced level of service for it.....would you be happy then??

I'm all for charging more to give more, but aren't you missing the point, that some fee hikes are down to rising costs - staff costs and minimum wage, social care levy / NI rise, software etc etc - its an inflationary rise to ensure that the accountants business doesn't go backwards and that the level of service provided can stay the same - its nothing to do with managing or mismanaging my 'brand'

I moan that a 4 pint bottle of milk if £2.40 in the co-op, it used to be £2.20. annoying yes, but I accept that i'm still going to get 4 pints, no more no less, cost of living always increases, there is no escaping that

Thanks (4)
Replying to Crouchy:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
15th Mar 2022 14:23

Hi there

Thanks for the comment. My article is not moaning about a price increase but is saying that the price increase could be more than the cost of living if there was a strategy in place behind it.

Everyone needs to be able to put food on the table, we all have business costs too. What I was actually saying is that by looking at it from a distance there may be a way to add value beyond the small %

I have no problem with paying my accountant more. In fact, I was hoping we'd have a discussion about how he could further support me and that would automatically add in greater cost for me which is ok.

Thanks (0)
Replying to philippa101:
avatar
By Crouchy
15th Mar 2022 15:00

if you wanted more of a service, why didnt you pick up the phone and ask for it? I'm sure your accountant isnt a mind reader

I'm pretty sure quite a lot of clients would be pretty hacked off if their accountants decided to charge more to be provided an unsolicted extra service they hadnt requested

your accountant is probably reading this and feeling totally hacked off

Thanks (3)
Replying to Crouchy:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
15th Mar 2022 15:30

Since when has anybody asked for that? Mind reader no but accountants provide a service and it's up to them to stay in touch over the year which is what my article was about.

If a client thinks it's an unsolicited expense or request then they are the wrong clients and haven't bought into the firm or the brand. This is meant to be a relationship

Thanks (0)
Replying to philippa101:
By Michael Beaver
16th Mar 2022 11:59

[quote=philippa101]

...but accountants provide a service and it's up to them to stay in touch over the year which is what my article was about.

Why is up to the accountant to stay in touch? As a business owner are you unable to articulate your needs, or at least have an idea of what further service you are looking for? Is your relationship with your accountant so poor that you're scared of picking up the phone to them first?

We interact with the client from our side at least twice a year doing compliance, sometimes more often if we provide payroll or VAT service. However there are some we only interact with once a year.

We make it VERY clear when onboarding that what they are paying for is not just the compliance but for our availability as well. However, we won't be calling them every month on the off chance they have a question or need something extra. We make it clear that the phone is there and we will pick it up when they call at any time during the year. And they can call about any accounting or tax topic, regardless of how silly they think the question is or how wild the idea.

The kind of client who says 'I pay you for a service and you should be keeping in contact with me', in my experience, is exactly the kind of client who will get angry because they didn't get advice that they never actually asked for, because they never thought to let the accountant know of a new situation or change of circumstance. Those clients are the ones we very kindly, but very firmly, show the door.

With over 700 clients I'd spend the whole time calling them saying 'do you need anything this month?' rather than actually doing any value add work at all. Or indeed actually helping those clients who do need it.

Thanks (0)
Replying to michaelbeaver:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
16th Mar 2022 14:11

Hi Michael

In many ways accountants are most qualified in telling business owners what they need rather than what they want. Don't always assume that business owners are always able to articulate that. Sure there are large businesses that are very clear , but equally there are many that are not.

As you say, there are clear moments in the calendar when you do interact and of course that's a priority. This article was really aimed at those who wanted to think about adding additional value beyond the confines of compliance and helping them to understand what the options are.

With a client base of over 700 clients it's impossible as you say to service them with a monthly call or whatever the promise is. It obviously depends on the number of team members you have and how many they serve too. It's also a case of strategy - do we go deep with fewer clients or less deep with more.

In your case, you'll have A, B, C, D clients and I'm sure you have a service level and journey mapped out to make sure each has clear levels of support. But at the end of the day, there will be those who are maybe a C but could potentially become a B with the right input.

Thanks for your reply, I know you don't agree but I value the input

Thanks (0)
Replying to philippa101:
avatar
By Open all hours
06th Apr 2022 20:51

With a client base of 70 or 700 it’s a doddle to send a weekly email. It won’t cover all bases all the time but. it will be a reminder that none of them are forgotten and we are just on the end of a ‘reply’ button.

Thanks (0)
Replying to Open all hours:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
07th Apr 2022 08:57

Yes agree with this. It should be part of your overall communication strategy however. What else do you do?

Thanks for the comment. Useful

Thanks (0)
Replying to Crouchy:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
15th Mar 2022 15:30

Since when has anybody asked for that? Mind reader no but accountants provide a service and it's up to them to stay in touch over the year which is what my article was about.

If a client thinks it's an unsolicited expense or request then they are the wrong clients and haven't bought into the firm or the brand. This is meant to be a relationship

Thanks (0)
Replying to philippa101:
avatar
By Crouchy
15th Mar 2022 15:47

oh dear

you are right it is a relationship, but that's a two way street, your article says you've had no contact with your accountant, which says you haven't needed anything from them (as per previous reply if you have, why havent you approached them) or you are the wrong type of client for you accountant.....are you really so needy that you expect them to be getting in touch every 5 minutes on the off chance you need extra support

If you suddenly charge more to provide XYZ, but the client has only requested ABC, it doesn't mean they haven't bought into the brand or your firm, it means that they only want or need ABC from your firm. if they want XYZ, they'll ask for it

Of course, if we think a client can benefit from an extra service, we'll advise them of it, but no one in their right mind would just start doing it without the clients permission and expect that they'll get paid for it

And do we want to look desperate, continually going to clients to ask if they want more?

Thanks (4)
Replying to Crouchy:
Mark Lee headshot 2023
By Mark Lee
16th Mar 2022 14:44

Crouchy wrote:

oh dear

And do we want to look desperate, continually going to clients to ask if they want more?

Hmm. I'd suggest there is a need for balance here.
No one is suggesting accountants should be "continually" doing anything. Rathe that an occasional call to see how things are doing - maybe just once or twice a year - is likely to be appreciated.

Far from making the accountant seem "desperate", most clients would see this as part of the pro-active approach so many of them (incl Philippa) say they want.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By SimonLever
13th Apr 2022 13:23

Rather than call them every month why not add value to your relationship with them. Have targeted e-mails that keep in touch but provide value for the contact.
Now is the ideal time to contact single director companies and suggest the best level of remuneration for them. An e-mail which provides them a choice but tells them that you are helping them save tax will be welcomed. There should be no quibble to a fee increase if you are providing them with this sort of proactive value.

Thanks (0)
Replying to SimonLever:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
13th Apr 2022 13:56

Yes, proactive and context specific is what you're saying I think.

Thanks (0)
Runagood - the business growth AI software system for accountants
By Runagood
20th Apr 2022 17:36

Yes Philippa
Vodafone have just informed me of the second price hike in 8 months (up from £18 pm - £26 pm) with as you say "no extra services". And neither does it mention my right to cancel. But if I login incognito, I'm offered half price as a 'new customer'. So much for the brand in my mind...
I advise accountants to talk 'investment' instead of 'fee' and show the client / prospect the bottom line that will result. So the brand equates with ROI rather than cost.

Thanks (0)
Replying to Runagood:
Brand and strategic digital marketing consultancy
By Philippa Haynes
20th Apr 2022 18:34

This is such a good example. Vodafone, like many, show a disregard for their loyal customers, courting only the new which we know long term is a dangerous game. It is also more costly at the end of the day. chasing with "cheap" also brings those sensitive to cost and always on the look out for the next deal.

I was talking to someone today who referred to "investment" as overall benefit (I think that was it), anyway, the meaning was similar. Investing in a good brand or accounting brand that knows its clients intimately and serves them accordingly starts to turn the fee conversation around.

Thank you for your comment

Thanks (0)