9am Lowdown: Bermuda tops worst tax havens list

Lowdown
AccountingWEB
Share this content

Good morning and welcome to Wednesday’s 9am Lowdown.

* * *

Bermuda tops worst tax havens list

Oxfam has released the ‘world’s worst’ corporate tax havens list, identifying Bermuda as the worst offender.

Oxfam ranked the 15 corporate tax havens, stating that these tax havens are the “ultimate expression of the global corporate tax race to the bottom.” According to the research paper, the Oxfam researchers assessed countries against a set of criteria that measured the extent to which countries used three types of harmful tax policies: corporate tax rates, the tax incentives offered, and lack of cooperation with international efforts against tax avoidance.

1 Bermuda

2 Cayman Islands

3 Netherlands

4 Switzerland

5 Singapore

6 Ireland

7 Luxembourg

8 Curaçao

9 Hong Kong

10 Cyprus

11 Bahamas

12 Jersey

13 Barbados

14 Mauritius

15 British Virgin Islands

Commenting on why it is “absolutely critical” the world establishes a worst tax havens list, Oxfam said: “Tax havens are frontrunners in a global race to the bottom on corporate tax. Yet every country is being swept up in this. In an attempt to attract business, governments around the world are slashing corporate tax bills – damaging their own economies, and those of other countries in the process”

* * *

HMRC abandons VAT colouring book plans

HMRC will not pursue unpaid VAT on colouring books sold before April 2017 after discussions with publishers, according to the FT.

HMRC wanted to add 20% VAT to the price of adult colouring books, used as mindfulness tools. Until then, publishers had treated these colouring books as zero rated. In a statement, HMRC referred to a 10995 court case regarding VAT of diaries and address books in their decision to back down on this VAT pursuit, which said these books must be designed to be “read or looked at”. 

Stephen Lotinga, chief exec of Publishers Association said: “We have been discussing the issue of VAT on colouring books with HMRC for some time and welcome the constructive manner in which that consultation was undertaken which led to the guidance published today.”

“The solution proposed is a very positive outcome for publishers, booksellers and consumers, and will ensure that the vast majority of colouring books remain free from VAT.”

* * *

Tax could force companies out of Scotland

The SNP’s refusal to implement the UK government’s tax cut for high earners will force companies out of Scotland, the Scottish Conservatives have claimed.

The Scottish Conservative party argues that companies will have to pay higher wages to keep highly skilled workers. According to the BBC, the Scottish government does not plan to replicate a tax cut for higher earners proposed by the UK government. The Scottish Conservatives said this will make Scotland “the highest-taxed part of the UK".

Conservative finance spokesman, Murdo Fraser said: "The reality of the SNP's tax grab is that firms may end up having to pay high quality staff a 'Scottish supplement' simply to persuade them to stay and work here”.

* * *

About Richard Hattersley

Richard Hattersley

Richard is AccountingWEB's Practice Editor. If you have any comments or suggestions for us get in touch.

Replies

Please login or register to join the discussion.

14th Dec 2016 09:55

One man's "worst tax havens" list is another man's "best tax havens" list.

Thanks (2)
avatar
14th Dec 2016 12:36

So low tax rates and tax incentives are automatically harmful?

Thanks (1)
14th Dec 2016 14:01

Only the third of Oxfam's criteria should be in point. If a country is aiding tax avoidance (or at least making dealing with it difficult) then that is a problem.

But to cite tax rates and incentives as "harmful" in themselves is ridiculous. If the UK tax rules allow profits earned in the UK to be legitimately diverted to a low tax country, then the problem is the UK tax rules, not the rates that other country charges.

Thanks (1)
avatar
15th Dec 2016 08:00

HMRC really blue it with that colouring book case eh?

Thanks (1)
to thegreatgrumbleduke
15th Dec 2016 10:07

Fantastic - it's only 10am and you've already won post of the day.

Thanks (1)
By Mike18
16th Dec 2016 11:22

So tax havens are getting support from accounting web users. Surprise! Look, the key points from Oxfam are the 'race to the bottom' and the damage to society.

Thanks (2)
to Mike18
18th Dec 2016 17:35

Mike18 wrote:

So tax havens are getting support from accounting web users. Surprise! Look, the key points from Oxfam are the 'race to the bottom' and the damage to society.

No one is supporting tax havens, we are simply saying that low tax rates themselves are not the problem. A low tax rate is only beneficial to a company if they can move their profits there.

To put this into context, the national US corporation tax rate is 35%. The UK rate is 20%. Are we therefore a tax haven that should get vilified simply because our rate is lower?

Thanks (1)
avatar
19th Dec 2016 08:58

It's called competition.

Once you get rid of it governments will charge more and more and get bloated and lazy rather than looking at what they can do to attract business to their shores. eg. infrastructure, stable legal system etc

Thanks (2)