HMRC hits back at carbon frauds

Kashflow logo
Share this content

Sarah Donald of law firm Dundas & Wilson outlines the problem of VAT carousel fraud in the carbon credits trading sector and assesses HMRC’s response.

Anyone navigating their way through the carbon credit trading legislation will understand its complexity but must also be aware of their company’s possible exposure to VAT carousel fraud.

Initial scepticism about the magnitude of VAT fraud in the carbon credit trading arena was answered swiftly back in August. HMRC zero rated transactions in the UK after the tax authorities in France and then the Netherlands had taken similar action following suspicious trading on the Bluenext Exchange in Paris. However, whilst HMRC’s actions may protect companies going forward, there is still the matter of the m...

Please Login or Register to read the full article

The full article is available to registered members only. To read the rest of this article you’ll need to login or register. Registration is FREE and allows you to view all content, ask questions, comment and much more.

About Sarah Donald


Please login or register to join the discussion.

By Anonymous
21st Oct 2009 17:18

Carbo Fraud
I thought the whole carbon thing was a fraud all along.

Thanks (0)
By uninet
22nd Oct 2009 18:16

HRMC Employment

Of course we will need more HMRC "experts" to keep this fraud under control.


Why don't we just scrap it and not bother?

Thanks (0)
By Anonymous
24th Oct 2009 13:01

EU could diminish VAT Carousel Fraud IF only additive returns we

As VAT is basically a French Invention (TVA - nicknamed "Tout va ajuter" i.e. everything goes up) in my opinion, it seems sensible to point out RE QUOTE then party E may export it to another European country and claim back the VAT from HMRC. Whilst party E may be completely unaware that there has been a fraud in the supply chain, it may nevertheless find itself the subject of legal proceedings by HMRC if it has not taken sufficient caution in its trading activities.  ENDQUOTE that EU could diminish VAT Carousel Fraud IF only additive returns were allowed.

In other words, the EU law could be modified to reflect the commercial world as it exists, rather than what "some sixth form swot economists" think it should be!

SUM UP: Each VAT returner would take the risk that VAT it has paid may not be reclaimable, unless it were a profitable entity! As this would of course put the total VAT revenue take up, if no other changes were to be made. So - to be revenue neutral - the VAT percentage chargeable values would have to be reduced!!


Everybody agree that VAT percentage chargeable should be reduced asap?

Thanks (0)