HMRC recalculations: Disaster recovery exercise

Car problems, red warning triangle!
istock_isayildiz_aw
Share this content

HMRC has started to recalculate the tax due for taxpayers who submitted their 2016/17 tax returns online before all the exclusions for online filing were put in place.

In return of the undead tax computations, Rebecca Cave explained how HMRC will be repairing the 2016/17 income tax calculations for an estimated 30,000 taxpayers. On 13 November, software developers received an email from HMRC’s Software Developers Support Team giving a little bit more detail.

The email tells us:

  • The “recovery exercise” will begin on 19 November 2018.
  • A total of 22 different exclusions that affected the calculations have been identified.
  • Affected taxpayers should receive a new SA302 by the end of November.
  • Copies will not be sent to agents.
  • Penalties will not be applied and interest on underpayments will not be charged provided the additional tax is paid within 28 days of the date of the notice (in many cases the taxpayer will have been overcharged and so entitled to a repayment).
  • Appeals against the amended SA302 (if appropriate) must be made within 30 days of the date of the notice.

The exclusion cases to be repaired in this recovery exercise have been listed as:

1) Non-UK resident – exclusions 57, 67 and 73:

  • 57 – Relating to the 7.5% notional tax paid on UK Dividend income.
  • 67 – Relating to the tax due on trust income.
  • 73 – Relating to the loss claimed.

2) Beneficial ordering – exclusions 68, 69, 70, 72, 76, 78, 79, 82, 83 and 85:

  • Relating to how the personal allowance and/or reliefs are allocated to ensure the allocation is most beneficial to the customer.

3) Dividend tax credit, trust and Lloyds – exclusions 62 and 75:

  • Relating to the tax calculation to give the relief due on apportioned income.

4) Marriage allowance transfer (MAT) – exclusions 66 and 66A.

5) Capital gains not calculating – exclusions 64 and 77.

6) Chargeable event gains – exclusions 74 and 81:

  • Relating to the top-slicing relief that is due.

7) Pension lump sum – exclusion 87:

  • Relating to the tax due on your state pension lump sum.

The exclusions that will generate the greatest number of recovery cases are those listed above under beneficial ordering.

Chargeable events

Watch out for chargeable event gains. Exclusion 81 was agreed following my representations to HMRC (and my article last year in Taxation Magazine). But only very recently have HMRC (again at my behest) agreed to remove exclusion 80 and confirm that the HMRC calculation was after all correct.

You may need to check whether your tax return software incorrectly calculated tax because of exclusion 80 and as a result, the client overpaid for 2016/17.

Correct now?

Will the repaired calculations be correct? I hope so – but if you want to check them for your client then run the figures through my free 2016-17 tax checker. Please let me know if you find any differences!

About Tim Good

Tim Good profile image

One of the founding partners of The Professional Training Partnership, Tim is also a director of PTP, PTP Interactive and Absolute Accounting Software and is chairman of The Tax Club. He is the author of three chapters in Tolley's Tax Planning and presenter of TAXtv.

Replies

Please login or register to join the discussion.

22nd Nov 2018 18:25

I saw this on the ICAEW news feed and was staggered to note agents will not be copied in.

This is such an arcane and complex situation, the ordinary taxpayer cannot be expected to know that HMRC's software was wrong, and has been corrected.

There is a very real risk here that clients will think that HMRC has 'found' an error agents have made.

Thanks (6)
avatar
to ireallyshouldknowthisbut
26th Nov 2018 09:58

I just hope clients don't leave it too long before they get in touch. I know some are wintering somewhere warm.

Thanks (3)
avatar
By djtax
26th Nov 2018 10:02

HMRC timing here sucks. Revised SA302s going out now, no copies to agents and a requirement to pay any extra tax within 28 days - doesn't half (or more) of the UK population go on holiday around the end of December most years...What planet do HMRC live in?

Thanks (3)
avatar
to djtax
26th Nov 2018 12:20

djtax wrote:

...What planet do HMRC live in?

... the one where Civil Servants collude around the good times to bury bad news.

The whole short notice and purposefully excluding agents is yet another stark illustration of HMRC's calculated duplicitous mendacity - their capacity to affront never ceased to astound.

Thanks (4)
avatar
26th Nov 2018 11:12

Well shouldn't it be overpayments refunded + 10% and a letter of apology , under payments written off. If you make the tax system so complicated that accountants tax inspectors and programmers cant work with it and there is only Tim in the whole country who can do this ....

Thanks (4)
26th Nov 2018 14:01

Quote:
Appeals against the amended SA302 (if appropriate) must be made within 30 days of the date of the notice.

Rubbish. No appeal is required, merely an objection. S9ZB(4) TMA 1970 - “A correction under this section is of no effect if the person whose return it is gives notice rejecting the correction”.

Thanks (2)
avatar
28th Nov 2018 07:56

Is this only for SA returns filed online using HMRCs software. If you used third party software to submit, will your clients still be affected?

Thanks (0)
to exceljockey
28th Nov 2018 16:48

Almost all third party software uses the HMRC calculator to do the tax calculation (so that the tax figures agree and the return is not rejected). If the third party software did not trap an exclusion case and allowed online filing then such a return should be picked up by this recovery exercise.

Thanks (2)