You might also be interested in
Replies (37)
Please login or register to join the discussion.
How is HMRC going to communicate this to businesses or are they assuming that businesses read HMRC statements?
The HMRC are meant to be writing to all VAT registered businesses. I was told in July that the HMRC was hoping to do this in September but this was not confirmed. However I heard in September on the agenda for the HMRC board for this month was the final rubber stamping of MTD for VAT. Due to today's announcement I assume that has happened so hopefully the letters will be sent.
I have not had my letter yet. I will report back when it arrives. I wonder what it will say (as every bridging software website I have looked at does not have downloads yet so I cannot see what I am supposed to do - I am not even going to spend any time emailing any providers yet until they have sometihng I can use which is bridging and is not cloud based nor am I going to train myself in excel until I have to)
Very badly, if this reaction from a confused business owner is typical...
https://www.ukbusinessforums.co.uk/threads/vat-returns-to-be-submitted-d...
Good link. I feel like those people on that link.
What would really help me now, this week, is if HMRC could tell me one provider with free bridging software I can download tomorrow and start learning how to use.
I have not seen free software I can download immediately anywhere, just companies wanting to take my personal data and register me as interested, not something I wnt to do.
It si a bit rich fo HMRC to say sign up now when as far as I know none of hte free providers have softwae you can download yet as HMRC has not specified yet. no one wants to commit to software that is not approved and ready surely particularly th ose of us using paper records and may have to learn to use excel and who do not and will not use the cloud.
The Lords sub committee on the finance bill has just taken evidence from the FSB which seems to indicate HMRC have not been perhaps as helpful as they might to small businesses on this.
They make it look so unattractive and say once you are in you are in - you cannot try and then stop it so who would want to be a guinea pig when there is hardly time to eat some days due to pressure of work?
"Those who trade with the EU, are based overseas, submit annually, make payments on account, use the VAT Flat Rate Scheme, and those newly registered for VAT that have not previously submitted a VAT return are currently unable to join. But they will be allowed access in the coming months."
WTF is that HMRC! With less than 6 months to go before go live date, we still have a list of exclusions as long as your arm. How can they be allowed to get away with this drivel?
Exactly anhd gosh loads of us will trade with the part of the EU which is not UK. I have clients who sometimes are abroad eg NL, Austria etc. I cannot be that unusual as a tiny one person VAT business that I have clients outside the UK. Not that I want to go anywhere near this nor buy or try any software until the last possible minute anyway...... sa it's going to be hard, take 10 - 20 hours of my time at least and will probably not work.
So these businesses are excluded from the pilot but are still mandated to start in April (some in Oct).
Trade with the EU? You buy one item from Amazon Lux or have an Irish service provider and you trade with the EU so surely this is a huge number of businesses? Loads of my clients have reverse charge on various apps/add ons etc.
Or Office 365! We got a letter from HMRC re 'what would happen if we get a no-deal' because they saw that we purchase goods from the EU. We're an accountancy firm! The only thing that I can conceive from memory is that we purchased Office 365 directly from Microsoft for a year. Meanwhile, clients who actually trade with the EU didn't get the letter. Brexit and MTD are both a shambles and a car crash waiting to happen. I had a lovely three week holiday in a non-EU country recently. It was bliss to hear nothing about either subject for three whole weeks!!
Per a tweet by Rebecca Benneyworth yesterday.
There is absolutely no doubt that #MTD will start on 1 April 2019. All businesses over VAT limit (and VAT registered) need digital records (which could be a spreadsheet) ASAP. Stop waiting for it to be cancelled and get with it now!
Her tweets are very pro MTD which is at odds with the rest of us. However I can only see pain and unpaid work and clients blaming advisors, whereas she has seminars lined up until she retires on this topic.
Rumour has it that people in business will have to keep records.
Oh Yes.... digital records.
This could be something of a burden for some of the people we deal with on the margins of society - still I don't suppose it matters at this stage as they won't be over the VAT threshold and I expect that with MTD they will ensure that they stay beneath the threshold even if it means having to put a few quid in their trouser pockets or taking a day off to play golf.
I am just not sure what HMRC thinks they are going to achieve with this - lots of redundancies in HMRC, I expect, so the quality of 'customer' (their expression not mine) service will reduce even further but it will stop us writing to them as computers don't take any notice do they?
Since the only way to get a response from HMRC these days is to lodge a complaint I hope that all the redundant staff end up in the complaints office.
What fun!
The way this is going is that I expect in 5 years time we are submitting a full nominal ledger on all businesses (including landlords) at least quarterly and possibly monthly. I also expect the payments of IT and CT are brought forward based on the submissions.
The HMRC dream is that everybody is under some sort of monthly PAYE system. They hate the self employed.
The information submitted will all be checked by AI and as you say less humans at HMRC!
On the whole this is the global direction of travel, not just the UK, with SAF-T (Standard Audit File for Tax) as the principle blue print.
Only a small handful of countries have made that journey so far, and the broad intentions of SAF-T have been interpreted in different ways.
MTD is just our flavour. It will take a while, but access to the source data doesn't seem like fantasy (it will just take a while *ahem*)
On this policy paper
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/making-tax-digital/overview-o...
I have sent this to HMRC but they dont reply :
Can anyone help ?
Dear Sirs
The new guidance is published today . Please can you provide a helpline number as I want to sign up all my clients so that any problems can be dealt with prior to mandation.
At the moment despite my putting forward issues regarding two clients we have had no feed back from you concerning specific problems. The various software companies are not helping and we don’t understand the software , its really complicated to use.
We want to sign up out clients and have created a ASA and now how to we sign people up – the advice on your website dosnt seem logical. You mention the old gateway. I am totally confused. At the moment I am unable to even file my own VAT return let alone that of my clients .
We need your urgent help on a client by client basis in particular we anticipate 14 clients will call us very soon for guidance.– I have a mix of clients that need help and we have no information from you to guide them.
So will the 6 month exempted categories (VAT groups etc) stili be able to use the existing HMRC online VAT return facility post 31/03/19 or what? This has been billed as being retained only for non MTD voluntarily registered businesses below the VAT threshold!
I don't tihnk that's clear. It sounds like they are going to retain it for those exempted people (charities etc) too. I wonder how they know who is who so they can work out who the "turn the tap off" as it were.
It sounds like we use the same log in details for the new system but does that mean those of us who log in to HMRC for income tax returns keep that gateway access for that purpose but lose it for VAT?
I have to say that I feel very strongly that as this MTD stuff is a further extension of taxpayers doing HMRCs job for them, that all costs, including software subscriptions, arising from e.g. transferring from perfectly good paper accounting, fees to professional support etc. should be 100% tax deductable.
Seems a reasonable quid pro quo.
I would imagine that HMRC couldn't put MTD for VAT back another year so they allowed themselves the 6 months (for complex business) just in case everybody not on board at the appropriate date.
So it would appear only those business in the cloud will have access to the pilot and the rest are still waiting for the software. Sounds par for the course.
We're getting to the messy end.
HMRC will tell clients about it sooner or later, but will gloss over the bit about needing new software and won't tell clients it will cost them more in software costs and accountants fees for absolutely no benefit to the client at all.
We'll then be left with cleaning up the mess and persuading people who don't use computers that they should now suddenly become computer whizzes so they can keep digital records.
I can't wait to wade through all those scanned receipts (not likely, clients don't bother as it takes time) which have been entered into the wrong section and taking three times as long to produce VAT Returns which big data analysis will then pick out transactions and automatically send out pointless queries.
Most of small client's reaction so far have been 'wait until April then deal with it, we're busy running our business the way we want to'.
I have just followed the link for Agents and tried to sign up to use the system in advance of the start date. It was for a Ltd company, not on flat rate, up to date with returns etc
but it would not work.
Said come back on 1st April. Not convinced it will ever work!
I just tried to sign up for my own VAT return and aborted the process which is unusual for me. When it said that I agreed to get emails and not letters , this was just too much. No terms or conditions were given and no guarantees. I would urge you not to sign up at the moment which would give the clearest indication yet to HMRC that this is ludicrous. I am very proactive with digital records but this is crazy. What are the benefits to anyone ?
I think unusually there is merit in waiting, a bit like those companies who deliberately wait for new technology to bed down so their competitors get the beta and test versions and suffer from them and only move in when absolutely mandated to do so.
Howeer I would like to download (not register for but download) free bridging software now just to have a go at using it and as far as I can see there is none I can download.
EnglishRose , I fear you may have a wait on your hands.
No software is ‘free’ - and even the options for bridging software will require some validation of who is using it. I would be very skeptial, and highly suspicious of any provider offering a free download trial, especially without a registration of some description.
I fear this is a big data security risk.
Choose names you know and trust, research, speak to the provider, do whatever you need to do that your data and systems will be safe.
Unfortunately this means you will inevitably have to either provide cash or your details.
I'd pay £10 for a digital download of bridging software for a one-off download I suppose which will take me through year 1 I suppose.
I still don't fully undertand this - what is an API etc.
So I learn how to use excel - ugh.... I put my invoices and expenses on an excel sheet. I go on a website and download free bridging software. that adds some kind of extra icon on the excel sheet I see on my screen eg it might say - "upload now to HMRC".
We get to April or 31 May filing date in my case and before then HMRC presumably had sent me some kind of new code numbers by post or told me where to go to register for a new kind of website HMRC are setting up for all this.
Then I go on to the excelt sheet with the new gizmo on it and I click upload directly from this sheet to the HMRC website I suppose and the gizmo embedded in the sheet or my computer can somehow communite with HMRC's website go take the data from the special excel sheet to HMRC's computer?
Is that the gist of it for excel plus bridging software?
Application Program Interface - it is something that enables the bridging software to exchange information with HMRC. Unlike GOV.UK where there is one page for all VAT businesses, I understand there are different APIs for different VAT businesses (eg voluntary as opposed to compulsory). Also, there is one API for submitting the VAT return, another for retrieving liability details etc. You don't have to worry about APIs, you 'just' decide which software you want and the software handles the APIs.I still don't fully undertand this - what is an API etc.
Mel Stride said in a recent article that he wants to keep regulations and taxes low for small businesses.
He also says in the statement that businesses can start to file their VAT returns online under the pilot (this is already mandatory) and that this will assist them getting it right first time. How does this change anything?
He also says that businesses use digital tools every day to help them operate, so tax should not be any different. If he has read the feedback surely he would realise that MTD causes additional costs and makes it much harder to operate?
I find this all so frustrating.
Unfortunately there seems to be two business worlds at the moment. Those that use tech to their advantage and are happy with it and those that don't use it because they want to, they use it because they have to. Now you cannot make a set of rules that don't cater for both (this is where Brexit breaks down). So the thing to do is to allow the transition on a natural basis for a few years until the business world as a whole are used to it, which I believe most of us talking about it have said that this should be a 5 year roll out at least.
If HMRC and Mel Stride etc wants a simple system why are they constantly fragmenting the tax system.
For VAT filing they will have to maintain a 2 tier system for ever and a day due to the ongoing exemptions.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/making-tax-digital/overview-o... says partnerships won't be able to join the public beta until 'early 2019'. When is 'early'? Most accountants will be working flat out with Tax Returns in January, so 'early' will be 01/02/19 at the earliest. Mandation is a mere two months later. This isn't Carter compliant.