Community Assistant AccountingWEB
Share this content
Tax
istock_tax_Drazen_

Accountants dismiss new TaxLab tool for taxing topics

by

Tax is complex, and explaining the intricacies of various tax policies can be confusing for both parties involved. But an attempt by the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) to demystify tax for tax novices has not impressed accountants.

8th Jul 2021
Community Assistant AccountingWEB
Share this content

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) has launched a new online TaxLab tool to help tax novices understand complicated policies.

Many small businesses have no idea of the inner workings of some of the most basic of tax policies. When it comes to getting the details right, this lack of background knowledge can make it difficult to let clients know what’s going with their tax liabilities, especially in the current climate of predominantly screen-based communication.

TaxLab

The IFS launched its new tax informative tool to address this knowledge gap. The IFS TaxLab is an immersive website filled with articles and resources exploring the nitty gritty of tax policies and explaining it all in plain English to make the detail accessible to tax muggles.

The site takes you through a range of policies including income tax, national insurance contributions, and corporation tax includes downloadable resources about the wider the tax system.

The IFS introduced the TaxLab as part of its  mission to “to provide better access to impartial information about how the UK tax system works, the effects it has on different people and businesses, and the options for reform. Everything on the site is either a verifiable fact or a conclusion drawing on the best possible evidence.”

The aim of TaxLab is to help small businesspeople better understand UK tax law and reduce the headaches of having to untangle the legal language it themselves.

Accountants not convinced

However, the accounting community was not entirely on board with the IFS tax policy tool. 

Although it seems a helpful idea, some doubted the rationale behind its creation: “In the 35 years since I left HMRC and started working in practice I have never once encountered a client who was interested in having tax policy explained,” commented AccountingWEB member TaxTeddy. 

Clients were far more interested in the law that needed to be applied rather than the policy that brought them there.

“Do we need another London-based, London-educated, London-centric body telling the rest of the UK how they think taxes ought to work?” questioned another member. “I’m not going to be referring anyone here because I disagree with their opinions, and it's not really a useful tool for providing facts on the tax system when the opinions are interspersed with no real indication as to what’s fact and what isn’t. I can do a better job explaining what my clients need to know myself.”

Community feedback

Owner and CEO of Avery Martin, Glenn Martin, was confused after reviewing the TaxLab with various clients: “I don’t really get it or what they are trying to do. All the data stuff, like how the government spend the money, is of little interest to most people and a Google search would be for those that do.

“They don’t really offer anything anyone with common sense would not know. People want to know useful information like how a car is taxed, how pensions work, or how to save tax. I don’t really know who the site is aimed at.”

As AccountingWEB member David Gordon put it, “If - Heaven forfend - I really do need to explain a tax point to a client, the last thing I do is quote tax rules. Unless I do wish the client's eyes to glaze over as they slip into a coma.”

Will you be using TaxLab to explain those tricky tax tips to clients? Let us know by commenting below.

Tags:

Replies (4)

Please login or register to join the discussion.

avatar
By Paul Crowley
08th Jul 2021 20:12

The existing comments in the article make it clear that it is not learning tool at all
No client has ever asked what the purpose and rationale is for NI
They can hover figure out that an employee on low earnings (MINIMUM WAGE) pays tax at 20% and NI at 12%
Total 32%
someone on £90,000 pays a total of 42% on the higher earnings
How can that be fair?
Higher rate tax is supposed to be double basic rate.

Thanks (0)
Replying to Paul Crowley:
avatar
By john hextall
09th Jul 2021 10:47

By my calculations, you pay 14% on 20k and 32% on 90k. Are you using different tax tables?

Thanks (0)
Replying to Paul Crowley:
avatar
By AndyC555
12th Jul 2021 14:04

Someone on £17,142 (minimum wage 37 hrs a week) pays £914.40 income tax, 908.80 NI.

Someone on £90k a year pays £23,432 income tax, £5,678.84 NI

The higher earner earns around 5.25 times as much as the lower earner
The higher earner pays around 16 times as much tax/NI

If the higher earner has children, he or she has also had all their Child Benefit clawed back.

The lower earner may be entitled to further benefits, especially if he or she has children.

Thanks (0)
avatar
By johnjenkins
09th Jul 2021 12:18

Great article. The reason for a particular law should always go hand in hand with the law itself. Then and only then can the law be changed to suite the intention. Of course some Accountants won't agree. Wonder why?

Thanks (0)